Confirmation of failures of the international phytosanitary system

California sycamore infested by PSHB; photo by Bea Nobua

Lantschner et al. (2026; full citations at the end of this blog) review global spread of an ambrosia beetle species complex, the polyphagous shot hole borer (PSHB, Euwallacea fornicatus). This complex has caused significant damage in southern California and is now poised to raze unique plant communities in South Africa, Western Australia, and possibly elsewhere. Dell, Xu, and Chi (2026) say that introductions of these species pose serious challenges to global biosecurity programs and forest health management.

Unfortunately, neither Lantschner and colleagues nor Dell, Xu, and Chi, nor even Pennisi’s summary of the situation in Science (2026) suggests the kind of bold changes to the international phytosanitary system needed to prevent repetitions of this disaster.

Ambrosia beetles are especially suitable study subjects for analyzing international movement of non-native species. Some reasons result from the beetle’s biology: they have broad host ranges, close associations with pathogenic fungal symbionts, cryptic biology, specialized breeding systems which allow extremely low populations to start an infestation, and the ability to establish across diverse climatic regions. Other reasons stem from the beetles’ frequent association with international trade in timber and/or ornamental plants.

PSHB’s Impact in California

California has been invaded by three species of Euwallacea — Euwallacea fornicatus s.s., Euwallacea kuroshio, and Euwallacea interjectus. The beetles vector three previously undescribed species of fungus that cause disease in host trees: Fusarium euwallacea, Fusarium kuroshium, and Fusarium floridanum.

Euwallacea fornicatus s.s. (polyphagous shot hole borer, or PSHB) came to attention in late winter 2012, when a new insect/pathogen complex was discovered causing damage to avocado trees in residential neighborhoods and a commercial avocado grove in Los Angeles County, California. Later studies determined that the beetle and its associated fungus had been in California since at least 2003 (Eskalen et al. 2013).

Over the nearly 15 years since its discovery, the PHSB/pathogen complex has spread across much of southern California. Populations are established in Orange, San Diego, Los Angeles, Riverside, San Bernardino, Ventura and Santa Barbara counties.   The separately introduced species Kuroshio shot hole borer (KSHB) was discovered in late 2013 in San Diego County. It has since spread to Mexico. Californians now track the two species as one; a map showing their current known distribution is posted here.

Box elder (Acer negundo) from Traité des Arbres et Arbustes que l’on cultive en France en pleine terre (1801–1819) by Pierre-Joseph Redouté. Original from the New York Public Library. Digitally enhanced by rawpixel.

Certainly a wide range of tree species face a challenge – as do their associated natural or anthropogenic systems. Nearly 600 plant species in more than 30 plant families are known hosts of PSHB worldwide (Ceriani-Nakamurakare, Johnson and Gomez, 2023). In southern California specifically, 65 woody species are able to support reproduction of both the beetle and the pathogen. The preferred and most susceptible hosts are several species in the maple (Acer), Parkinsonia, plane (Platanus), oak (Quercus), and willow (Salix) genera. Box elder (A. negundo) is so susceptible that it is considered a sentinel tree. The following additional native species are also hosts: big leaf maple (Acer macrophyllum); California sycamore (Platanus racemose); three Populus species, P. fremontii (Fremont cottonwood), P. nigra (black poplar), and P. trichocarpa (black cottonwood); Valley oak (Quercus lobata); and three willows – black (Salix gooddingii), red (S. laevigata) and arroyo (S. lasiolepis). Three more oaks – coast live oak (Q. agrifolia), canyon live oak (Q. chrysolepis), and Englemann (Q. engelmannii) – are less susceptible; they suffer branch dieback rather than death.

Given PSHB’s wide host range, it is not surprising that Lynch et al. (2025) found that regions at risk of future invasion are determined largely by climate rather than host abundance. Areas where temperatures are sufficiently warm to allow the beetle to pass through at least five generations per year include parts of southern California, drier regions of the San Francisco region, and portions of the Central Valley. A risk map for California is available here.

The E. fornicatus and E. kurosio combined outbreak has killed large numbers of trees in southern California’s coastal counties – although I have been unable to find an estimate.  Meanwhile,  additional outbreaks have been detected. The PSHB was found in the San Jose area in 2023. This location is close to the state’s Central Valley – where vulnerable almond, pistachio, and other crops grow (Pennisi, 2026). A third, related species, E. interjectus, also turned up. See a map of distribution of all three Euwallaceae established in California here.

A dozen years after their presence was detected, Dr. John Kabashima led a lobbying effort that persuaded the state legislature to fund a collaborative program comprising an action plan, five research initiatives, and a comprehensive outreach and education strategy across the state (Dell, Xu, and Chi). These funds ran out at the end of 2025, while the infestation continues.

As of the first half of 2026, official monitoring projects were reported to be under way in four of the seven invaded counties, Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside, and San Bernardino. This effort is now being cut back because state funding supporting it has expired. For example, Los Angeles County carried out surveys in 240 parks in 2025, but planned to survey only 146 in 2026. While in most parks the infestations were described as light or moderate, five parks with heavy infestations were detected in 2025; trees in a sixth park were reported to be recovering.

Attention continues from the California Invasive Species Advisory Committee, Los Angeles and Orange County Master Gardeners Emerging Tree Pests Groups, University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources (UC ANR) representatives, UC Cooperative Extension from various counties, and Cal-Fire. These organizations seize opportunities to educate the public about the shot hole borers’ impacts. 

Dr. Paul Rugman-Jones of the UC Riverside Department of Entomology is studying possible biocontrol agents. In early 2026 he was working w/ APHIS to set up research colony of Phymastichus nudusdraco, a wasp native to Taiwan that parasitizes PSHB there. He and a postdoc continues surveys on that island and elsewhere in Southeast Asia. Dr. Rugman-Jones is also searching for potential natural enemies already established in southern California.

From Asia to a World-wide Pest

The polyphagous shot hole borer has been detected in nine countries on five continents since 2000 (Lantschner et al. 2026). Many of these introductions have occurred since stricter biosecurity measures, i.e., International Standard of Phytosanitary Measures #15, came into force with the purpose of reducing introductions of insects associated with wood packaging material.

By combining data on the distribution of the species’ 36 haplotypes, phylogenetic relationships and dates of first detections, Lantschner et al. (2026) have identified seven independent introduction events of E. fornicatus: to the continental United States, Hawai`i, South America, Central Europe, Spain, Türkiye, and South Africa. I am unsure why this list does not include the introduction to Israel, detected in 2009.  

Lantschner et al. (2026) suggest two contradictory explanations for this explosive spread. On one hand, beetle populations in the species’ native Asian range might have increased recently. On the other, higher trade volumes from these countries have opened new pathways for transport. I favor the second explanation since exports from China have risen from less than $500 billion in 2003 to approximately $4 trillion in 2025. Exports from Vietnam rose from about $22 billion to $500 billion over the same period.  

Lantschner and colleagues compare the PSHB’s range of introduced populations to the more restricted locations invaded by another species in the genus, E. perbrevis. They believe that the latter is more restricted to humid tropical regions. It has been introduced to several islands in Oceania, and possibly northern Australia (Queensland). Many of these countries might be less active in global trade than the countries to which PSHB has been introduced. This shield is shrinking, however, as more countries expand their trade. Lantschner et al. (2026) warn that E. perbrevis’ establishment in subtropical FL and Panama indicates it might also tolerate broader climatic conditions than previously assumed. They think that E. perbrevis populations established in Central America might expand into northern South America, including the Amazon basin and the Brazilian coast. Another area at risk is central Africa.

Neither Lantschner et al. (2026) nor Dell, Xu, and Chi (2026) discuss why other species in the genus have been introduced to fewer locations. Euwallacea kurosio and E. interjectus are also established in California, but nowhere else.  

PSHB Threatens Severe Impacts in its Introduced Ranges Other Than California

The outbreak in South Africa occupies the largest geographic region of any PSHB outbreak on Earth (Bierman, Roets, and Terblanche 2022). Dell, Xu, and Chi (2026) anticipate significant economic costs tied to the need to remove affected urban trees. The article in Science (Pennisi 2026) quotes Stellenbosch University ecologist Francois Roets as saying the long-term consequences of these forest invasions will be “substantial”.

Erythrina caffra in South Africa infested by PSHB; photo by T. Paap

In South America PSHB has spread 3,500 km along the coast since it was detected in Brazil in 2020. While local experts Ceriani Nakamurakare and colleagues (2023) mention attacks on non-indigenous landscaping favorites, Dell, Xu, and Chi (2026) report that in Uruguay a significant number of native species have proved to be reproductive hosts for the beetle.

The PSHB invasion in Western Australia is particularly worrying. The list of hosts has grown rapidly. While 69% are non-native plant species, 8.7% are regionally indigenous and another 21.3% are native to other parts of Australia. Initially authorities attempted to contain the outbreak. They spent $40 million pruning or removing 5,000 trees in the Perth region (Pennisi 2026; unclear whether the figure is in U.S. or Australian dollars). They then decided that eradication was infeasible and shifted the program to management focused on minimizing the risk of further spread. In November 2025, the National Management Group allocated $16.5 million (Australian) to this effort. The state of Western Australia committed $18.8 million for the 2025–26 period, plus $5.1 M for a tree recovery initiative (Dell, Xu, and Chi 2026).

To date, the total budget for PSHB eradication/management from all funding sources has surpassed $92 million. Under the long-term management approach, local governments and communities must assume significant additional expenses for tree removal and replacement (Dell, Xu, and Chi 2026). This team critiqued Australian officials for being slow to engage the public in PSHB detection.

According to the article in Science, the PSHB outbreak has not yet reached the habitats and hosts most likely to support establishment. There, its population could skyrocket (Pennisi 2026).

swamp banksia (Bansia littor …) one of the endemic plant species in Western Australia vulnerable to PSHB; photo by Gnagarra via Wikimedia

Upon detection of PSHB in Western Australia, authorities in the state of New South Wales (more than 3,000 km away on the other side of the continent) stepped up surveillance and risk assessment. They determined that 47% of urban trees in Sydney are susceptible to PSHB. Authorities added key PSHB hosts to the list of sentinel trees (i.e., Acer, Cupaniopsis, Ficus, Robinia). The presence of the closely related Euwallacea perbrevis has complicated efforts (Carnegie et al. 2026)

Dell, Xu, and Chi (2026) also describe damage caused by the beetle-fungus complex in Vietnam – that is, in the native range.

Future Damage

Models developed by Lantschner et al. (2026) suggest where populations of E. fornicatus might spread under the rising temperatures and shifting precipitation patterns caused by climate change. The population currently established in southern California could spread into the southeastern U.S., eastern Mexico, and parts of Central America. [I note that many proven host species are either native to or widely planted in southern U.S. states.] Populations in South Africa might spread into the northern part of temperate and subtropical regions of Africa. Beetle populations established in Spain, Israel and Türkiye might spread across the Mediterranean basin. The population in Western Australia could spread to the country’s east – as noted, NSW authorities are already alert to this possibility. Lantschner et al. (2026) raise the caveat that for many of these range expansions to occur the PSHB must cross substantial gaps of unsuitable habitat. Given that their earlier description of how frequently E. fornicatus has exploited human transport to cross oceans, I wonder that they don’t concede that this prerequisite is not likely to be a significant barrier.

Fixing the Problems

Of the references cited here, Pennisi’s article in Science has probably reached the broadest readership. However, it doesn’t discuss how governments and stakeholders can improve the international phytosanitary system. I fear readers will conclude that we are helpless to stop spread of this species or other introductions of similar organisms. The scientific papers offer some steps to improve prevention and detection of ambrosia beetles being transported by trade.

Dell, Xu, and Chi (2026) offer a welcome focus on policy-level changes. I agree with their assertion that real progress depends on more than scientists’ discoveries. They advocate shifting the international phytosanitary system from reactive eradication programs to a more proactive, adaptive, and resilient forest biosecurity systems based on the “One Biosecurity” concept. The proposed new approach will require stronger international collaboration on surveillance, diagnostic protocols, and information sharing; long-term investment in research and surveillance; and improved integration of science, policy, industry, and community. They propose a new framework to facilitate scientists’ engagement with policymakers.

However, in praising South Africa and California for utilizing citizen science and extensive community involvementDell, Xu, and Chi (2026) do not recognize how important individuals have been. In California, John Kabashima led the lobbying campaign to obtain needed government funding. https://www.nivemnic.us/?p=1275

Dell, Xu, and Chi (2026) also address scientists’ criticism of the practice of relying on lists of regulated organisms. This approach allows introduction of lesser-known species with undetermined threat status.

Dell, Xu, and Chi (2026) weigh in on details of surveillance, inspection, regulation, and management responses specific to various settings. For example, noting that only a small proportion of internationally traded wood and wood products is inspected at ports of entry, they advocate tighter phytosanitary certificates (presumably in addition to the ISPM#15 mark) and greater engagement by those in the supply chain. These authors also advocate for more intense inspection of high-risk trade pathways, enhanced surveillance and trapping around ports, and establishment of national pest surveillance programs. They expect emerging technologies e.g., molecular diagnostics, eDNA detection, remote sensing, machine learning, and AI-assisted surveillance to support major improvements in detection and management.

I applaud their attention to the demonstrated inadequacies of ISPM#15 as regards continuing introductions. To see my past advocacy on this topic, scroll down below “Recent Posts”, “Recent Comments” and “Archive” to “Categories and click on “wood packaging”.

Regarding management strategies, they describe challenges hindering use of chemical attractants and treatments, use of entomopathogenic fungi as biological control agents, and breeding trees resistant to the beetle-fungus complex. Nevertheless, they consider it essential to preserve the genetics of endangered species.

Dell, Xu, and Chi (2026) also review gaps in scientific understanding of ambrosia beetles, their host interaction and fungal symbionts. Closing these gaps is essential for developing more effective long-term management strategies. They assert that the substantial increase in funding needed to do this work is warranted given the level of damage caused by the PSHB and other ambrosia beetles.

Lantschner et al. (2026) tie their recommendations to ambrosia beetles specifically. They say that the different invasion patterns of E. fornicatus and E. perbrevis demonstrate that surveillance and management tactics must be species-specific. (This necessity adds to the complexity and resource demands of the task.) They also urge study of the PSHB’s broader microbiome, which influences beetle fitness, symbiosis stability, and invasion success. Research should also explore the extent to which environmental stressors, e.g., drought, temperature extremes, and mechanical damage, influence PSHB attacks across different environments; and whether semiochemicals have any role in insect behavior.

Finally, Lantschner et al. (2026) warn that species’ occurrence data based solely on climatic factors might not accurately reflect its possible range. This is because both biotic interactions and land-use patterns play a role in determining where a pest is present.

SOURCES

Bierman, A., F. Roets, J.S. Terblanche. 2022. Pop structure of the invasive ambrosia beetle, Euwallacea fornicatus, indicates multiple intros into South Africa. Biol Invasions (2022) 24:2301–2312 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10530-022-02801-x

Carnegie AJ, Summerell BA, Trollip C, Tovar F, Smith DI and McDonald J (2026) Sentinel trees for early detection of non-native forest pests and pathogens in AU.

Front. For. Glob. Change 9:1801183. doi: 10.3389/ffgc.2026.1801183

Ceriani-Nakamurakare, E. A.J. Johnson and D.F. Gomez. 2023. Uncharted Territories: First Report of Euwallacea fornicatus (Eichoff) in South America with new reproductive hosts records. Zootaxa, 5325 (2), 289-297. https://doi.org/10.11646/zootaxa.f325.2.10

Dell, B., W. Xu, and N.M. Chi. 2026. Polyphagous Shot Hole Borer, a Global Threat to Forest Plantations, Green Infrastructure, and Biodiversity: Status, Challenges, and Solutions. Forests 2026, 17, 832

Lantschner, M.V., E. Ceriani-Nakamurakare, A.J. Johnson, A.I. Cognato, S.M. Smith, D.F. Gomez. 2026. Invasion history reconstruction and potential distribution of the ambrosia beetles Euwallacea fornicatus and E. perbrevis (Coleoptera: Scolytinae), two global emerging pests. J Pest Sci 99, 100 (2026). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10340-026-02070-w

Pennisi, E. 2026. Tree-killing beetle is spreading to urban forests around the world. As researchers piece together the pest’s global trek, countries are working to contain the growing threat. Science 15 July 2026

Rabaglia, R.J., S.A. Dole, and A.I. Cognato. 2006. Review of American Xyleborina (Coleoptera: Curculionidae: Scolytinae) Occurring North of Mexico, with an Illustrated Key. Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 99: 1034–1056.

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

 

U.S. imports continue growing … as does risk of introductions

As I have documented in the past, wood packaging (crates, pallets, spools for cable, etc.) remains a pathway for introduction of tree-killing insects, including those that vector pathogens. Visit previous blogs describing continuing failures of the international standard by scrolling below “Comments” and “Archive” to “Categories” and click on “wood packaging”.

Because of the associated risk, I report on volumes of incoming trade containers, called “TEUs”. This acronym stands for “twenty-foot equivalent”. I focus on expanding import volumes from Asia into East and Gulf Coast ports because 1) ecological similarities between East Asia and eastern North America facilitate establishment of species from Asia into this region; 2) China has a particularly poor record of non-compliance with the international standard; 3) U.S. phytosanitary officials at eastern ports might be less prepared to handle the volume.

So what is the situation in Autumn 2026?

U.S. imports have been rising – despite tariffs, trade wars, shooting wars, and weather challenges. The following information comes from articles posted by the Journal of Commerce. Unfortunately, JOC articles are behind a paywall.

In 2025, the top nine U.S. ports handled 49.5 M total TEUs, loaded and empty, the third highest number after 2022 and 2021. People in trade expect the overall U.S. container trade to grow between 2 and 3% annually. A 3% growth rate would put total U.S. container handling (imports and exports) at just over 66 million TEUs by 2035 (Michael Angell, Oct 20, 2026).

Higher import volumes are linked to the data center construction boom (Mark Szakonyi, October 2, 2026). For example, the Port of Houston saw a 41% increase in imports of wiring, electrical transformers and switches, refrigeration equipment, and lithium-ion batteries – to 80,953 TEUs (Michael Angell, October 5, 2026).

U.S. east coast ports saw a 28% increase in volumes from Southeast Asia over the past two years (Michael Angell, Oct 20, 2026). In recent months, however, U.S. importers have shifted sourcing back to China because of easing U.S. tariffs and lower energy costs than in Southeast Asia (Mark Szakonyi, October 2, 2026.

The ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach have been handling record or near-record container volumes over the past four months as retailers responded to changing tariff deadlines and supply chain challenges caused by congestion at Chinese ports and drought-caused draft limitations at the Panama Canal (Bill Mongelluzzo, October 30, 2026).

Supply chain challenges in addition to the shallow water in the Panama Canal (which has restricted ship passages) include 13 typhoons in East Asia, some of which have forced closure of export harbors in China, Taiwan, and possibly Japan (Keith Wallis, October 23, 2026). This month devastating floods in the Four Corners area have completely disrupts rail transport from the California ports to the Midwest and East (Bill Mongelluzzo, October 27, 2026).

A looming complication is the possible strike by security personnel at Los Angeles and Long Beach (Bill Mongelluzzo, October 30, 2026; Ari Ashe, October 27, 2026).

Port of Houston

Imports from Asia to East and Gulf Coast Ports Continue to Rise

Houston saw the largest increase percentage-wise of major U.S. ports from Asia — up 11.7% from the same eight-month period (through August) in 2025. This year, 792,419 TEUs from Asia have entered Houston. (As noted above, 10% of these containers held equipment for data centers). Overall, through this period, Houston received 5% more loaded import TEUs (1.4 million) than over the same period a year ago. Other ports also received higher numbers of containers from Asia, although significantly lower percentages: Savannah imports rose by 4.5%; Los Angeles by 4%; and New York-New Jersey by 3.2%. Not all ports saw gains: Seattle/Tacoma received 14% fewer containers from Asia, Charleston 6.4% fewer, Oakland 3% fewer (Michael Angell, October 5, 2026).

Expansions Continue at East and Gulf Coast Ports

See earlier reports on these expansions by scrolling below “Comments” and “Archive” to “Categories” and click on “wood packaging”.

Container ports along the U.S. East and Gulf are in the process of or planning major expansions through the 2030s in anticipation of increasing volumes from places other than China. Projects include expanding the ports’ rail networks to reach inland markets now served mostly by the West Coast. Three projects will ramp up capacity to gradually to 6.8 million TEUs by completion a decade from now. Baltimore and Wilmington, Delaware broke ground earlier this year on their expansions. Savannah has obtained needed permits for constructing a third terminal. It also will build a new container yard. A fourth project at Norfolk will eventually add another 3.4 M TEUs to East Coast capacity. Farther in the future, Philadelphia has obtained funding to double its capacity, which would add another one million TEUs (Michael Angell, October 20, 2026). Savannah was the port of introduction of the redbay ambrosia beetle and its associated fungus as well as two conspicuous arthropods that are not forest pests, the East Asian Joro spider and yellow-legged hornet. Charleston might have been one of many ports of introduction of the Asian longhorned beetle.

dredging the Port of Savannah

Some ports have found a different, probably cheaper, way to increase capacity. The Port of New York-New Jersey is upgrading equipment so it can stack containers up to six high, thus storing a third more containers in the same space as currently. This adjustment could add another 1.5 M TEUs to the port’s current capacity of ~10 M TEUs (Michael Angell, October 20, 2026). The New York metropolitan area has been the site of numerous pest introductions, most notably the original establishment of the Asian longhorned beetle.

Asian longhorned beetle

Gulf Coast ports are also expanding. New Orleans has awarded preliminary contracts for building the Louisiana International Terminal. Houston is fast-tracking a permit for a third container terminal. These projects could add ~6.3 M TEUs in new container handling capacity on the Gulf Coast through the 2030s. More is planned. Corpus Christi has signed a lease to build its first container terminal and Mobile is dredging its harbor. These projects would raise the Gulf Coast container handling capacity to 7 million TEUs (Michael Angell, October 20, 2026).

Port expansion is not limited to the United States. The port of St. John, New Brunswick, announced it will receive C$463 million (US$330 million) from federal and provincial governments and the private sector to increase container handling capacity from 850,000 TEU to one million TEUs. The project includes dredging to allow deeper-draft ships to call more frequently, expanding port warehouses, building a new customs inspection facility, and improvements to the port’s rail infrastructure. Import volumes are growing: the 239,364 TEUs handled in 2025 was a 29% increase over 2024. Port St. John already can handle super-post Panamax ships with a 56-foot draft. (Michael Angell, October 22, 2026). Halifax was the port of introduction of three tree-killing pests: beech bark disease in the 1890s; brown spruce longhorned beetle in 1999; and beech leaf-mining weevil in 2012.

symptoms of beech bark disease; photo courtesy of Bugwood

Labor unions at Halifax and Montreal have recently signed agreements that make strikes unlikely (Journal of Commerce staff | October 23, 2026).

UPDATE

US imports from Asia in October jumped to 1.9 million TEUs — an all-time high for any month.

The ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach have handled the highest cargo volumes in their history. Port officials expect the complex to handle 268,000 incoming TEUs during the week of November 16th. That number will increase to 315,000 next week before dipping to 289,000 laden TEUs for the week of Nov. 22-28. The typical import total is about 200,000 laden TEUs per week (Bill Mongelluzzo, November 16, 2026).

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

New Zealand prepares – but perhaps not sufficiently

Metrosideros bartlettii; photo by Bodleye1 via Wikimedia Media

I rejoice that New Zealanders are exploring the risk to Aotearoa New Zealand and South Pacific islands posed by the rapid ‘ōhi‘a death (ROD) pathogens, Ceratocystis lukuohia and C. huliohia. See Marroni et al., – full citation at the end of this blog.

Marroni et al. (2026) note that several species in the genus Ceratocystis cause severe disease in native and cultivated plants following their introduction to new regions. Several of the more than 40 species in the genus have demonstrated a capacity to infect a wide range of hosts and, in some cases, to attack new hosts in novel regions.

The stakes are high. These islands are home to 54 of the 58 species in the Metrosideros genus – the genus of Hawaii’s ‘ōhi‘a lehua trees (Metrosideros polymorpha) – an endemic species of immense ecological and cultural importance. Aotearoa New Zealand alone has 12 native Metrosideros species. Four of these species are already under conservation threat. Only 31 Bartlett’s rātā (M. bartlettii) trees remain in the wild. Another species, pōhutukawa(M. excelsa), has declined 90% in abundance since Polynesian and European settlements — although it is not formally listed as threatened. (Why not?) Trees on other South Pacific islands are also apparently at risk. Metrosideros collina is widespread on these islands and is known to be susceptible to C. lukuohia. Its close relationship to both Hawaiian species and several species on the other islands suggests that related taxa across the region might also be vulnerable.

Metrosideros excelsa; photo by Ceili & Roger via Flickr

Marroni et al. (2026) worry that non-Metrosideros species (native or introduced) could also be at risk. They cite the recent finding on Kaua‘i of C. lukuohia in dead camphor trees(Cinnamomum camphora) and death of 60–100% of kiwifruit (Actinidia chinensis) in laboratory tests. So far, coffee, avocado, macadamia, mānuka (Leptospermum scoparium), and two species invasive in Hawai`i, rose apple (Syzygium jambos) and strawberry guava (Psidium cattleianum) have proved not susceptible to C. lukuohia in laboratory tests.

I applaud the New Zealanders for initiating tests of these species’ vulnerability. Preliminary results indicate that M. excelsa might be less susceptible to C. lukuohia than the Hawaiian species. M. perforata (white rātā) and M. fulgens (climbing rātā) have been found susceptible to C. lukuohia.  Pathogenicity tests are under way on additional New Zealand Metrosideros species. Marroni et al. (2026) call for screening of all Metrosideros species. They also suggest that New Zealand plant species – not just Metrosideros spp. – growing in botanical gardens or amenity plantings in Hawai’i should be monitored – application of the “sentinel tree” concept.

The scientists are also evaluating climatic factors. Although most Ceratocystis spp., including the two ROD species, are found primarily in tropical regions, some species cause disease across a broader climatic range. Models indicate that some parts of North Island are suitable now for ROD establishment. Several of the vulnerable species [M. excelsa, M. robusta (northern rātā), M. bartlettii and M. umbellata (southern rātā)] grow on that island. Low winter temperatures appear to preclude establishment on South Island at present. However, rising temperatures associated with global warming is expected to greatly expand ROD’s potential distribution to include nearly all of North Island and most of the South Island (see Figures 1a and 1b in the article). Marroni et al. (2026) say that changes in precipitation – extremely important in disease establishment – are more difficult to model. Many South Pacific Islands probably provide highly suitable climatic conditions year-round.

Worrying Conclusions About Risk

While I admire the New Zealanders’ efforts to prepare, I worry that Marroni et al. (2026)’s conclusions about the level of introduction risk are too optimistic. I fear they put too much faith in the country’s strong phytosanitary policies.

The most likely pathways of introduction are movement of infected plants, their wood, or associated soil or insects. These vectors might be moved during trade or carried by tourists.

The New Zealand Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) applies tight requirements on imports of all nursery stock of known Ceratocystis host plants (prompted by a desire to mitigate the risk of introducing the C. fimbriata sensu lato complex). These plants must be inspected both before export and at the port of entry – including testing for the presence of a pathogen and – when indicated — treatment and/or quarantine. Any intercepted putative Ceratocystis species is subject to further diagnostic testing, and infected material is either destroyed or managed according to MPI protocols. Since 2010 New Zealand has prohibited importation of whole plants and cuttings of myrtaceous species (including the Metrosideros genus) from Australia because of the presence of Austropuccinia psidii, causal agent of myrtle rust disease. New Zealand does allow import of tissue culture plantlets from Australia, India, and the United States. Given these stringent phytosanitary requirements and the absence of plant material imported from Hawai`i, Marroni et al. (2026) concluded that the risk of introducing the two ROD pathogens is “low”.

Movement of wood could transport aleurioconidia of C. lukuohia and C. huliohia – thick-walled asexual spores that can survive in infected ‘ōhi‘a wood for at least 12 months. So all wood products derived from infected trees, including logs, timber, firewood, chips, shavings, sawdust, and other wood particles can potentially carry the pathogens. Importation of wood products is managed under seven different standards. New Zealand imports wood products primarily from North America, Southeast Asia, Pacific Islands, and Australia. Marroni et al. (2026) report that various Ceratocystis spp. have been detected on timber originating from South Pacific and Asia multiple times.

Another type of wood imports is wood packaging material – crates, pallets, spools for cable, etc. Marroni et al. (2026) call the treatments prescribed by ISPM#15 – debarking, heat treatment or fumigation – highly effective in eliminating woodborne pathogens. There have been no detections of Ceratocystis spp. on ISPM#15-compliant SWPM entering New Zealand. Consequently, Marroni et al. (2026) consider the risk of introduction via this pathway to be “low”.

Marroni et al. (2026) do express concern that ambrosia beetles could be introduced via trade in nearly any form. In Hawai`i, the beetles’ frass (wood particles, faeces and beetle fragments) is considered to be a major pathway for spread of the ROD pathogens. Frass can be carried considerable distances on the wind during storms. The frass can also be moved on tools, machinery or footwear.

The New Zealand Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) prohibits importation of soil; this is enforced by inspection of incoming goods, machinery, containers, and visitors’ footware. They note that despite these measures, accidental intro of soil is still possible, especially via used agricultural machinery and vehicles. One study found soil contamination on 93% of sea containers and flat-rack containers arriving from several Pacific nations. This soil contained viable plant material, plant pathogens, and invertebrates.

Large numbers of New Zealanders and other Pacific Islanders visit Hawai`i. They could carry ROD propagules back to their home islands in soil on contaminated footwear, clothing, camping equipment, etc. NZ inspectors have found high incidences, counts and diversities of viable bacteria, fungi, nematodes, seeds, and several arthropods on footwear of arriving aircraft passengers. Although Marroni et al. (2026) to not explore this topic in detail, National Park Service and botanical garden websites reveal that ROD is present at several of the sites very popular with tourists. These include Kīlauea, Kīpukapuaulu, the ʻŌlaʻa rainforest, Thurston lava tube, and lower-elevation sections of the Kahuku unit of Hawaii Volcanoes National Park; the Hawaii Tropical Botanical Garden on the Big Island; and Limahuli Garden on Kauai. Overall, the authors consider the risk of introduction by this pathway to be “moderate”.

‘ohi‘a trees above trail to Thurston lava tube, Hawai`i Volcanoes National Park; photo by F.T. Campbell

If Ceratocystis lukuohia and C. huliohia were introduced to Aotearoa New Zealand or South Pacific islands, the risk of spread throughout the region seems high. There is the high volume of people and goods – including vehicles – moving among the islands. Wind storms might carry infected frass or insects from one island to another (Austropuccidia psidii is thought to have been introduced to New Zealand from Australia on prevailing winds). All these islands have feral and domestic mammals whose rooting and trampling can wound the trees, exposing them to infection by the pathogen. In New Zealand this risk is greatly exacerbated by the damage caused by the invasive Australian common brushtail possum (Trichosurus vulpecula), which feeds on tree buds and foliage and incidentally strips the bark and breaks branches.

My Concerns

  • Marroni et al. (2026) pay very little attention to the risk of introduction from the native habitats of Ceratocystis lukuohia and C. huliohia. They focus on imports and visitors from Hawai`i. These imports are dominated by aircraft and aircraft parts, scrap metals, gas turbines, seafood and beverages. The imports of primary agricultural or forestry products are in lower volumes. No nursery stock comes from the Islands.

But the Hawaiian outbreaks are caused by introduced pathogens.The native range of the species more virulent in Hawai`i, C. lukuohia, is in Latin America. The native range of C. huliohia is in Australasia! I wish Marroni et al. (2026) had explored the volume and type of imports from these regions.

  • As readers of this blog know, I do not share Marroni et al.’s (2026) sanguine evaluation of the efficacy of ISPM#15 in preventing introduction of wood-boring insects or – especially – fungal pathogens. See this blog describing the impact of polyphagous shot hole borer in one of many places where it has been introduced – perhaps via wood packaging. Or visit other blogs describing continuing failures of the standard by scrolling below “Comments” and “Archive” to “Categories” and click on “wood packaging”.
  • Most host vulnerability testing has focused on vulnerability to C. lukuohia. While C. huliohia is less virulent on Hawaii’s ‘ōhi‘a trees (Metrosideros polymorpha), I think it is unwise to assume that it will behave similarly on naïve tree species on New Zealand or other Pacific islands.
  • Marroni et al.’s (2026) do not acknowledge the difficulties in detecting pathogens on imported plants. See previous blogs describing continuing introductions of pathogens on plan imports by scrolling below “Comments” and “Archive” to “Categories” and click on “forest health” or “plants as vectors”. Perhaps the New Zealand procedures are sufficiently robust to overcome weaknesses detected in the U.S. and elsewhere … but that is not clear.
  • New Zealand scientist do not know how the oomycete Phytophthora agathidicida which kills the endemic kauri tree, Agathis australis was introduced. Does this situation conceal some other pathway?
a kauri tree; photo by F.T. Campbell

Uncertainties acknowledged by Marroni et al. (2026)

  • Hawai`i adopting regulations in 2016 to prohibit movement of M. polymorpha plant material from infected regions; this was six years after the disease was first detected. The disease was detected on Kaua‘i in 2018 and 2019, later on Maui and O‘ahu. Do these outbreaks demonstrate the limits of regulation? Or were these outbreaks initiated before the regulation was implemented—given the frequent lag in detection?
  • Asymptomatic infections have been detected on M. excels. Might other species also harbor undetected disease?
  • Scientists don’t know which species of Metrosideros trees, ambrosia beetles, or Ceratocystis fungi are established on which Pacific islands? Their presence or absence is relevant to the possibility of step-by-step spread of the pathogens.
  • Scientists don’t know how the pathogen might respond to seasonal temperature variations on New Zealand.
  • There is very little information on whether tissue culture plantlets can transmit Ceratocystis spp.
  • New Zealand has 12 native and 12 introduced species of Scolytinae, including Xyl. saxesenii [which has transmitted C. lukuohia and C. huliohia under lab conditions]; and Amasa truncata, an Australian ambrosia beetle species implicated in mortality of trees. There is little data regarding which insects associate with Metrosideros.

  • Proposed solutions

Marroni et al. (2026) say New Zealand’s recent sobering experience with myrtle rust https://www.dontmovefirewood.org/pest_pathogen/ohia-rust-html/ demonstrates the importance of quick action if a pathogen is introduced. Suggested priorities are to strengthen pathway management, improve surveillance in climatically suitable regions and at high-risk entry points, and research to address major knowledge gaps relating to host range, climate suitability, potential vectors, and dispersal. Scientists should test a broader range of possible hosts, including representative native forest species and economically important fruit and commercial forestry crops. Other studies are needed to determine which ambrosia beetle species utilize Metrosideros trees.

Pathologists should clarify which Ceratocystis species are already present in New Zealand and the South Pacific. Currently, only Ceratocystis fimbriata sensu stricto is recognized as occurring in New Zealand. However, New Zealand shares many fungi from other taxonomic groups with native forests in Asia and Australia, so Marroni et al. (2026) expect that some Ceratocystis species in the Austroasian clade might also occur naturally in New Zealand without causing obvious disease symptoms. Research is also needed to illuminate the influence of seasonality and local microclimates on disease outbreaks. A better understanding of these variables will inform long-term biosecurity and forest health planning.

Marroni et al. (2026) note that protecting Aotearoa New Zealand forests and primary industries requires collaboration of researchers, biosecurity agencies, Māori and Pacific local communities, and policymakers. They advocate a multidisciplinary approach that considers biological, cultural, and social factors.

Palau islands; photo by Luka Peternal via Wikimedia

Tree Mortality on Palau

Fear of spread of tree-killing Ceratocystis species across Pacific Island groups is not theoretical. In late 2021 people noticed extensive mortality of mature udeuid (Manilkara udoido) trees in Palau, an independent country in the Micronesian Islands east of the Philippines – so in the North Pacific. Udeuid is a culturally and ecologically important forest tree endemic to just one of the Palauan islands, the largest, Babeldaob Island (Johnson et al. 2025).

Losses exceeded 50% in several areas within the species’ core range. Koch’s Postulates determined the causal agent to be Ceratocystis manginecans, a Brazilian species associated with major disease outbreaks in Asia and elsewhere. Extensive damage to large udeuid trees caused by Typhoon Surigae in April 2021 might have contributed to the outbreak by creating wounds for infection. Four years after the initial detection trees continue to die. This is the first report of C. manginecans on the genus Manilkara andits first detection in the Pacific Islands. Johnson et al. (2025) conclude that C. manginecans poses a serious threat to native forests and cultivated crops in Oceania.

SOURCES

Johnson,J.A., M.A. Hughes,P.I. Bennett,O. Sadang,  K. Roy,  D.R. Kroese,  P.G. Cannon,  N.B. Klopfenstein,T. C. Harrington, and Mee-Sook Kim. 2025. First Report of Ceratocystis manginecans Causing Udeuid (Manilkara udoido) Wilt in Palau Plant Disease December 2025  https://doi.org/10.1094/PDIS-07-25- 1554-PDN 2025

Marroni, M.V., M.R. McNeill, R.E. Campbell, P.R. Johnston, T. Waiariki, A. Puketapu, W. Awarau‑Morris, J. L. Hasna, B. S. Beresford, J. Tyson, B. Weir, G.R. Smith, M. Padamsee, J.K. McCarthy, T.R. Etherington, B. Ganley, B.C. Luiz, L.M. Keith. 2026. The risk of rapid ‘ōhi‘a death to Aotearoa New Zealand and South Pacific. Biol Invasions (2026) 28:207 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10530-026-03896-2

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

Wood Packaging: additional information re: continuing introductions

LEAD Technologies Inc. V1.01

Twenty-four years ago the international community adopted ISPM#15 with the aim of reducing forest pest introductions via the wood used to make crates, pallets, and other forms of wood packaging (SWPM). Over that period questions have been raised about its efficacy. See the analyses by Haack et al. I have posted numerous blogs about wood packaging introductions, focused on the United States. To review these, on this website, scroll below the “Archives” to “Categories”, click on “wood packaging”.

Scientists continue to analyze data on wood borer introductions to explore patterns and evaluate the standard’s efficacy. Two recent articles focus on woodwasps in the Siricidae (Nardi et al. 2026) and ambrosia beetles in the Euwallacea complex (Lanschler et al. 2026). Full citations for both are at the end of this blog.

Sirex woodwasps

S. noctilio in Argentina; photo by Paula or Vicki Klasmer via Bugwood

A group of scientist led by D. Nardi surveyed woodwasp introductions to the United States, Canada, and New Zealand to determine historic and current patterns. They found that:

1) Nearly all Sirex woodwasps (84.2% – 97.6%) are transported in wood packaging.

2) While most introductions originated in the woodwasps’ native regions of Europe and Eastern Asia, accompanying high volumes of commodities imported from those regions, interceptions from the Southern Hemisphere have increased recently. Nardi et al. speculate that Asian countries might use softwoods (conifer species) less often for SWPM than do Europe and North America. Certainly the most infamous invasive wood borers from Asia are those that attack hardwoods, e.g., Asian longhorned beetle, emerald ash borer, invasive shothole borers.

3) Widespread adoption of ISPM#15 has significantly reduced interception, establishment, and damage associated with Siricids in the U.S., Canada, and New Zealand since 2002. However, continued detection of live Siricids in wood packaging demonstrates the need for strict enforcement of the standard’s provisions and potentially adoption of additional mitigation strategies.

4) Data collected by phytosanitary agencies of these importing countries is sometimes too limited to support needed analyses of trade patterns and risk. 

  • U.S. phytosanitary agencies identified less than 10% of the intercepted woodwasps to the species level, whereas Canada identified 25% and New Zealand 75%. Identification of the intercepted woodwasp and its country of origin is critical for effective biosecurity. Nardi et al. (2026) express consternation that only 17.8% of interceptions were identified to species level. Even worse, U.S. phytosanitary officials identified less than 10% of the intercepted woodwasps to species. Canadian officials identified 25%, and New Zealand officials identified 75%. Yes, the taxonomy of the family is complex and in flux. And U.S. port staff must process orders of magnitude more interceptions of woodwasps than do either Canada or New Zealand. However, to understand which species are approaching American borders USDA APHIS (which performs the identifications) needs to provide specialized training and apply modern tools e.g., barcoding, molecular diagnostics. CBP and APHIS must also allow adequate time to process the detection before determining the fate of the shipment.
  • U.S. authorities also did not document the country of origin of 83% of shipments associated with Siricid-infested wood packaging intercepted. New Zealand authorities recorded the country of origin of 78% of intercepted shipments, Canadians of 90%.
  • Lack of information on sampling effort impedes exploitation of valuable info. Haack et al. (2014) discuss this obstacle in detail. Nardi et al. (2026) note that changing inspection and reporting priorities – especially when not explicitly described – hamper analysis of which factors explain variations in interception rates over time.

5) Interceptions of Siricids on wood packaging from regions outside the species’ native range have been increasing since the 1960s. Overall, 2.2% of the 504 interceptions named to species level were imported from countries to which they are not native. This included 12.3% of Sirex noctilio (from North America, the Neotropics, and Africa); 3.2% of Urocerus gigas (from North America and the Neotropics). 

These secondary invasions are often from “bridgehead” populations in the Southern Hemisphere. Nardi et al. (2026) worry that such invasion bridgeheads established in trade hubs could speed up biological homogenization of their region.

6) Only a few of the more than 100 species in the family have established in novel regions although many additional species have frequently been intercepted in wood packaging by port inspectors. The species that have established are Sirex noctilio (introduced from Eurasia to North and South America, Australia, New Zealand, and South Africa); and two North American species: Urocerus albicornis (introduced to Europe and Asia) and Sirex obesus to South America. This pattern suggests that biological, environmental, or dispersal barriers interfere with establishment of other Sirex species even when they are transported to new regions.

exotic pine plantation in New Zealand; photo by Jon Sullivan via Flickr
  • One example might be Sirex juvencus. Although it has been intercepted 215 times by one of the three countries, it has not established outside its native range. Nardi et al. (2026) note that the species prefers spruce (Picea spp.), which are much less commonly planted in Southern hemisphere plantations and around the Northen Hemisphere than the pines (Pinus spp.) that support establishment of S. noctilio and U. gigas.
  • The role of the associated fungi is another factor. Nardi et al. (2026) note that another woodwasp species, Xeris spectrum, has not established in New Zealand despite being intercepted often by that country’s phytosanitary officials and presence of suitable hosts. They note that is species does not transport the symbiotic fungi on its body as do other woodwasps. Instead it oviposits on trees already infested with Amylostereum fungus that was injected by an earlier invasive woodwasp.  (A successful biological control program has reduced infestations of S. noctilio, so pine plantations are again widespread on the islands.)

Nardi et al. (2026) warn about several cryptic dangers. First, horizontal transfer of associated symbiont basidiomycete fungal species has been documented: Amylostereum fungal strains from European S. noctilio to American Urocerus species. Such transfers might increase the pathogenicity of formerly benign introductions. Second, scientists don’t yet understand the probable effects of climate change on insect and fungal species’ life cycles. They mention specifically the Asian species Sirex nitobei because its hosts are widespread Pinus species and it has been detected repeatedly, esp. on dunnage.

Nardi et al. (2026) suggest that officials should consider these ecological factors in assessing the risk of new introductions of specific species. I counter that the underlying rationale for adopting ISPM#15 was recognition that trying to manage individual species or countries of origin would not be effective. Instead, I advocate much more assertive enforcement of the standard.

PSHB damage to Harepephyllum caffrum tree in South Africa; photo by Trudy Paap

Invasive shothole borers

Based on analysis on distribution of haplotypes, phylogenetic relationships and dates of first detections, Lantschner et al. (2026) identified seven independent introduction events of the polyphagous shot hole borer (PSHB) Euwallacea fornicatus: to the continental U.S., Hawai`i, South America, Central Europe, Spain, Türkiye, and South Africa. Most apparently originated directly from the species’ native range, although some evidence of likely secondary spread between already invaded regions. Several of these introductions – Israel (2009), South Africa (2016); Brazil (2020), Argentina and Australia (2021), Spain (2022), Uruguay (2023), and Türkiye (2024) – occurred despite stricter biosecurity measures, specifically ISPM#15.

The United States (California) experienced two additional invasions by Euwallaceae in the 2020s: by PSHB E. fornicatus (in San Jose) and a new species, E. interjectus. This makes a total of nine separate introductions.

Lantschner et al. (2026) suggest two opposite explanations for why so many introductions of this group of species from Asia have continued since ISPM#15 came into effect. Their suggestions are that either beetle populations in China, Taiwan, and/or Vietnam grew, thus increasing the pool of potential invaders/propagule pressure, or that increased international exports from these countries opened new commercial pathways. Certainly the latter has occurred. According to Google, exports from China rose from less than $500 billion in 2003 to ~ $4 trillion in 2025. Exports from Vietnam rose from ~$22 billion to $500 billion over the same period.

To be fair, most consider that the principal pathway for movement of species in the Euwallaceae complex is the trade in ornamental plants. In addition to the introductions listed above, E. fornicatus populations have been detected in greenhouses or botanical gardens in Italy, Germany, the Netherlands, and Poland. All have been reported as eradicated (Lantschner et al. 2026). I recently posted a blog discussing the widespread failure of the international phytosanitary system to stem introductions via this trade.

A second group of scientists (Dell, Xu, and Chi 2026) worry that E. fornicatus has spread especially rapidly in South Africa and South America. Already the outbreak of Fusasrium disease in South Africa is the largest the world: it is present in every province except Limpopo. The disease is recorded on 162 tree species, 78 of which are indigenous to the country (Townsend, Hill, Hurley and Roets 2025).

The introduced ranges – sometimes called bridgeheads – create conditions under which the pest can more easily spread further. Lantschner et al. (2026) suggest that the PSHB population established in southern California could spread into the American southeast, eastern Mexico, and parts of Central America. The population in South Africa might expand into other temperate and subtropical regions of Africa. Beetle populations established in Spain, Israel and Türkiye might spread across Mediterranean basin. Population in Western Australia could spread to eastern regions. They note that achieving some of these dispersals would require crossing substantial gaps of unsuitable habitat. They don’t mention that human transport has moved many populations of wood-boring beetles across unsuitable habitat! As I blogged earlier, officials in Sydney, Australia, determined that 47% of trees in the city are vulnerable to PSHB.

SOURCES

Carnegie AJ, Summerell BA, Trollip C, Tovar F, Smith DI and McDonald J (2026) Sentinel trees for early detection of non-native forest pests and pathogens in AU. Front. For. Glob. Change 9:1801183. doi: 10.3389/ffgc.2026.1801183

Dell, B., W. Xu, and N.M. Chi. 2026. Polyphagous Shot Hole Borer, a Global Threat to Forest Plantations, Green Infrastructure, and Biodiversity: Status, Challenges, and Solutions. Forests 2026, 17, 832

Lantschner, M.V., E. Ceriani-Nakamurakare, A.J. Johnson, A.I. Cognato, S.M. Smith, D.F. Gomez. 2026. Invasion history reconstruction and potential distribution of the ambrosia beetles Euwallacea fornicatus and E. perbrevis (Coleoptera: Scolytinae), two global emerging pests. J Pest Sci 99, 100 (2026). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10340-026-02070-w

Nardi, D., K.E. Wagner, S.F. Ward, A.M. Liebhold, E.G. Brockerhoff, R.M. Turner, J.J. Riggins. 2026. Global movement of woodwasps (Hymenoptera: Siricidae) inferred from border interception records Biol Invasions (2026) 28:167 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10530-026-03881-9

Townsend, G., M. Hill, B.P. Hurley, and F. Roets. 2025. Escalating threat: increasing impact of the polyphagous shot hole borer beetle, Euwallacea fornicatus, in nearly all major South African forest types. Biol Invasions (2025) 27:88 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10530-025-03551-2  

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

Science advances re: ALB & EAB – cause for hope?

Science continues to provide new hope for management of some of the tree-killing insects introduced to North America.

searching for ALB; photo by USDA

Asian longhorned beetle

USDA Forest Service and APHIS scientists have developed an Asian Longhorned Beetle (ALB; Anoplophora glabripennis) Eradication and Risk Tracking (ALBERT) 1.0 toolkit. Trotter et al. (2024) believe that the toolkit will improve the efficiency of ALB eradication programs by better estimating changing infestation risk in real time and comparing efficacy of various management strategies in those circumstances. Managers can thus set priorities for surveys and eradication efforts, optimize surveys, and improve eradication outcomes. Improved efficiency will also reduce long-term management costs.

Data on dispersal and infestation risk are analyzed at the hectare level. Inputs are contemporary, so they reflect hectare-scale changes in risk level and ALB detectability simultaneously with program implementation. Managers and stakeholders can track and visualize the distribution of risk on the landscape. In the example, the risk of infestation is shown by the color and height of the surface on the landscape.

I note that the research was completed two years ago. I wish the USFS “Rooted in Research” brief had discussed whether programs managing extant ALB infestations are using the tool – and finding it useful.

Suppressing emerald ash borer populations

black ash swamp via Flickr

Minnesota authorities and scientists wish to protect the expansive black ash (Fraxinus nigra) swamps located mostly in the central & northern portions of the state. There, the emerald ash borer (EAB; Agrilus planipennis) has not yet spread to all vulnerable locations. They consider that use of pesticides is not concerned feasible in these locations. And two of the introduced biocontrol agents have limited efficacy. One of the wasps—Tetrastichus planipennisi— can oviposit in EAB larvae only in trees with thin bark, that is trees smaller than 16 cm dbh. A second wasp, Spathius agrili, doesn’t persist in northern regions – i.e., northern Minnesota!  Therefore they are seeking additional management tactics workable in natural mature ash stands across northern North America.

Peters, Rajtar, & Blanchette (2025) are testing whether useful levels of suppression can be provided by release of entomopathogenic fungi (EPF). They are building on earlier studies link? that determined that one entomopathogenic fungus isolate, Beauveria bassiana, showed promise in reducing EAB population growth. This fungus is available as a commercial product.

Peters, Rajtar, & Blanchette (2025) tested isolates from five genera = Beauveria, Purpureocillium, Metarhizium, Clonostachys, & Samsoniella. They found that Beauveria pseudobassiana, Beauveria bassiana GHA, Metarhizium sp. Meta, & Purpureocillium sp. consistently reduced EAB mean survival time (MST) and probability of survival over time.

They also tested use of an inoculation method different from that used in the earlier studies:  autodissemination devices (ADDs). The devices expose adult EAB to the fungal spores using baited Lindgren funnels with non-stick surfaces hung in the canopy of an infested ash tree. Infected beetles transmit the fungus to others during mating. In a Canadian study, this method of infecting EAB adults with an isolate of B. bassiana CFL-A caused rates of infection up to 40% and a significant decrease in EAB pop growth rate over a 3-year period.

Scientists have isolated and identified 1,126 fungal isolates associated with EAB larval galleries from trees growing across Minnesota. Eight percent of these isolates are entomopathogens. Some of these isolates have been proved to kill EAB eggs. In this study Peters, Rajtar, & Blanchette (2025) tested the fungi’s efficacy against adults and whether the ADDs system inoculates sufficient numbers of beetles.

They found that five of the fungal isolates significantly decreased the mean survival time of EAB adults post-exposure and the probability of EAB survival over time. These were Beauveria bassiana GHA, B. pseudobassiana EAB 16.8 & B. pseudobassiana EAB 53-5, Metarhizium sp. Meta, and Purpureocillium sp. EAB 59-16-2. They are most promising isolates for future study. Peters, Rajtar, & Blanchette (2025) discourage further consideration of isolates in the genera Samsoniella and Clonostachys because of disappointing reductions in adult beetle survival.

The probability of survival of beetles in the negative control groups differed significantly between the two experiments. The authors say they can only speculate about the reason because many external factors influence EAB adult lifespan. Among such factors are a) the longer storage period for insects used in the first experiment; b) differences in nutrient quality or microbiomes of ash leaves provided during incubation; or c) health of trees from which the beetles had been collected.

Peters, Rajtar, & Blanchette (2025) say the effectiveness of these fungi and this inoculation method must now be tested under field conditions. One concern: the fungal inoculum can degrade due to exposure to the environment while it is in the trap. A second concern is that the fungus might grow across the inoculum pouch unevenly, thereby undermining equal delivery of conidia to each beetle. They call for  research to optimize the type and/or formulation of inoculum used in ADDs to prolong fungal viability in the field.

an ash in a suburban setting; photo by F.T. Campbell

While I am cheered by the prospect of conservationists having new tools to counter the EAB infestation, I am concerned by how slowly work pursuing possible use of entomopathogens is proceeding. Peters, Rajtar, & Blanchette (2025) refer to several past studies that reached similar findings. Why has this knowledge not been applied in the field already? Is it due to the intrinsic difficulty of detecting and working with the fungi? Lack of funding for non-commercial approaches? Leaders’ narrow focus on strategies already in use? Some other complication?

SOURCES

Peters, C.J.; Rajtar, N.N.; Blanchette, R.A. Entomopathogenic Fungi from MN Are Virulent Against Emerald Ash Borer, Agrilus planipennis Fairmaire (Coleoptera: Buprestidae), Adults in a Laboratory Autodissemination Device Assay. Forests 2025, 16, 1742. https:// doi.org/10.3390/f16111742

Trotter, R.T., III; Warden, M.L.; Vazquez, R.J.; Ryan, J.K.; Pfister, S. 2024. ALB Hazard Management and Monitoring Version 1.0: an assessment and tracking tool for Asian longhorned beetle eradications in the United States. Gen. Tech. Rep. NRS-222. Madison, WI: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Northern Research Station. 24 p. https://doi.org/10.2737/NRS-GTR-222.

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

Port of Houston expands – is the region ready for incoming wood-borers?

Barbours Cut terminal, Port of Houston; photo by Patrick Feller via Flickr

I blogged recently about ports in the southeast dredging channels and taking other actions to increase the number of container ships they can service. Michael Angell of the Journal of Commerce reports that the Port of Houston is competing vigorously for visits by ships from Asia. Of course, rising ship visits increase the opportunity for Asian pests such as Asian longhorned beetle or several ambrosia beetles in the Euwallaceae complex to invade the Gulf Coast region. (The emerald ash borer is already present in Texas.)

Considering the immediate future, the Port of Houston is expanding capacity of its two existing terminals. The Port is dredging portions of its channel down to a 46-foot depth. It expects to complete dredging of the main channel to 55 feet – the depth of Norfolk currently by ten years from now.

One of the existing terminals, the Bayport container terminal, handles most of the trans-Pacific Asia services coming into the Gulf Coast. Two new berths and storage yard space are being added, so that Bayport will be able to handle five super-post-Panamax ships simultaneously. The other terminal, Barbours Cut terminal, is also being renovated to improve handling of super-post-Panamax ships. At full buildout, the Bayport and Barbours Cut will have capacity for handling 8 million TEUs per year.

Houston has begun design work for a third container terminal. At full capacity – more than a decade from now — this third terminal will handle another 4 million TEUs. The project has been approved by the Federal Permitting Improvement Steering Council for streamlined environmental under the 2015 FAST Act. This program does not alter any applicable statutory or regulatory requirement, or guarantee approval. It seeks to expedite lawfully mandated environmental and other review through standardized interagency consultation and coordination practices. It also created a public online tool to track progress in completing these requirements. 

Through May 2026, Houston handled 502,387 TEUs in container imports from Asia, up 10% from the same period in 2025. The number of container ships over 10,000 TEUs in capacity calling at Houston doubled, from four in the second half of 2025 to nine during the first half of 2026.

Port of Long Beach

Houston ranked fifth in container volumes during this period. Los Angeles was the top port, with 1,974,330, followed closely by Long Beach with 1,851,159. Together, the two California ports received more than seven times as many containers as Houston. Houston is competing with other ports in the Southeast. Savannah still handles more than a third higher numbers than Houston, at 823,823 containers. The Port of Virginia (see earlier blog) received 285,046 containers, and Charleston only 256,499 Both were decreases from the 2025 number. All three southeastern ports saw small decreases from their 2025 numbers.

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

U.S. Imports from Asia rise … & as more regions expand ports, the pest risk spreads to new places

Pananax ship; photo by 2005emsaguinden via Wikimedia

Imports from Asia, specifically China, had surged in the first half of 2025 as importers tried to get ahead of new tariffs. Blog They then fell sharply, although there was also a shift in Asian suppliers from China to Vietnam and India. At the end of 2025, experts expected the slump to persist into 2026. However, now we learn that U.S. imports from Asia jumped 13% from April to May, to 1.68 million TEUs (Michael Angell, Journal of Commerce, June 16, 2026). According to Politico, the shift to importing goods from Vietnam, and to a lesser extent to Thailand and Indonesia, has continued.

American cities continue to compete for to build larger ports so they can receive more cargo. Of course, more cargo means more incoming containers. As my blogs document (click “wood packaging” in the “Categories” section below the “Archives”), containers and especially the crates and pallets inside them too often transport wood-boring insects and other invasive species.

My source of information on these developments is from the Journal of Commerce website. Unfortunately, access is blocked by a paywall.

Recent reports concern port cities dredging and widening their ports in hope of attracting increased import volumes.

Norfolk; photo by PghPhxNfK via Wikimedia

Norfolk, Virginia

This month the Virginia Port Authority (VPA), Governor Abigail Spanberger and other federal, state, and local officials inaugurated the Port of Norfolk’s expanded capacity. At 55 feet, Norfolk is now the deepest and widest port along the East Coast. The project, begun in 2019, will allow Norfolk to handle vessels carrying up to 18,000 TEUs [twenty-foot equivalent containers]. Authorities are encouraging ocean carriers to call there.

The port was visited by 1,497 container ships over the past 12 months; nearly a quarter had a capacity greater than 11,000 TEUs.

Virginia’s container volumes grew on average 3% annually between 2017 and 2024. In 2025, total container volume fell 8% from 2024 because shippers hoped to avoid tariff deadlines by unloading cargo at a first or second port of call. Virginia was the six-busiest US port for imports this year through May, handling 635,205 TEUs. That was up 2.6% from the same five-month period a year ago. To attract shippers to Norfolk as a first or even second port of call for more container services, Virginia Port Authority CEO Sarah McCoy said, Virginia needs to emphasize rail links. This involves expanding the region’s distribution center network.

The project to dredge and widen the port began in 2019. The total project has a budget of $1.4 billion. The project included adding two ultra-large container vessel (ULCV) berths at each of its two container terminals. The final component is to renovate the North Berth, including developing a fifth ULCV berth, plus four new ship-to-shore cranes and semi-automated stacking cranes in its container yard. Completion is scheduled for mid-2027. At that time, the port’s total handling will reach 5.8 million TEUs. The International Longshoremen’s Association (ILA) is contesting installation of semi-automated stacking cranes in a series of lawsuits.

Other East Coast ports are also adding terminal capacity. This includes the Port of Baltimore, where a shipping company is developing a container terminal that includes handling two ULCVs simultaneously. Apparently they are not deterred by the months-long closure of the Port of Baltimore caused by a ship colliding with a bridge downstream from the port.  

[Information from Michael Angell, Senior Editor, East Coast Ports. “Norfolk aims to be preferred USEC gateway with deeper port” June 18, 2026]

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers dredge in the Savannah River

The Port of Savannah remains dominant. In 2025 Savannah and the roll on-roll of facility in Brunswick together handled nearly 5.7 million TEUs, an increase of 2.6% or 146,000 TEUs compared to 2024. Even so, Georgia Ports is financing a $4.5 billion port and inland infrastructure plan which will add five new container berths in Savannah, the most new berths of any U.S. port and one new RoRo berth in Brunswick. Port officials brag about their rapid turnover of cargo from ship to rail. Forty-two double-stack trains per week take this cargo to Atlanta, Memphis, Nashville, Charlotte and Orlando. The Port Authority also operates two inland terminals – in in Chatsworth and Gainesville, Ga.

Corpus Christi

As I have reported in previous blogs, Gulf Coast ports are also upgrading to receive more shipments. DP World, a Dubai-based terminal operator, is negotiating to develop a container terminal at the Port of Corpus Christi. This would open this port to container logistics.

Corpus Christi is already the third-busiest port in the US by gross tonnage, behind Houston and South Louisiana. The bulk of cargo is petroleum and bulk commodities. (In past years, dunnage associated with bulk commodities proved to cause pest-infestation problems in nearby Houston.)

dunnage piled on the dock at Houston; photo by S. Useman

Last year Corpus Christi completed an eight-year, $625 million project to widen and deepen its main shipping channel (from 47 feet to 54 feet). The expansion allows visits by super-post-Panamax container vessels.

[Information from Michael Angell, Senior Editor, East Coast Ports. “DP World begins talks with Corpus Christi for container terminal project” June 16, 2026]

Warehouse Capacity

Leaders of logistics managers note that importers and domestic manufacturers are diversifying their supply chains – both warehouse facilities and shipping routes – because of ongoing supply chain disruptions even years after COVID 19. While many industrial warehouses across the U.S. still have vacancies (averaging above 7%), some markets are filling up. They mention Chicago, Indianapolis, Memphis, Dallas, and Kansas City. These cities’ warehouse vacancies average ~5%. Indianapolis leads; asking rents for industrial space there have climbed more than 50% over the past five years. Phoenix also anticipates increased demand for space, although its current vacancy rate is 10.6% – the highest vacancy rate of the 25 largest markets.

The move away from Los Angeles-Long Beach began years ago. To move freight inland, shippers need options, particularly access to intermodal rail.

shipping containers at Long Beach in the early 2000s; photo courtesy of Bob Kanter of the Port of Long Beach

The experts attribute this growth to the need for more flexibile supply chains and demand for materials used in constructing data centers. Demand for the second category is reportedly strongest in the Southeast, followed by interior central markets.

[Information from William B. Cassidy, Senior Editor, Trucking. “US warehousing expanding faster at key inland hubs” June 18, 2026]

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

Funding for USFS & APHIS – first Congressional actions

ash trees (Fraxinus spp.) killed by EAB along Mattawoman Creek, Prince Georges County, Maryland; photo by Leslie A. Brice

I report here on action so far on funding vital agencies in Fiscal Year 2047 (which begins on October 1, 2026). I describe the various programs roles in addressing the invasive species threat briefly in my earlier blog.

USDA Forest Service

The House Appropriations Committee approved the FY27 Interior Appropriations bill (which includes the USFS) in early June. I greatly appreciate Congress’ continued support for two USFS programs that are vitally important in protecting resilience of the Nation’s forests in the face of invasions by non-native pests and plants: Research and Development and Forest Health Management (in the State, Private, and Tribal lands division). The Trump Administration had – for the second year in a row – called for ending these programs’ specific appropriations.  

Research and Development

In my testimony I had asked the Subcommittee to maintain funding for R&D at the Fiscal Year 2026 Continuing Resolution level of $308 million. Instead the Subcommittee ignored the Administration’s request and provided $295 million – a fairly small reduction under the circumstances. Funding for the Forest Inventory and Analysis (FIA) program continues to see small increases — to $34 million.

While there is no specific line item for invasive species in the R&D budget, the report does encourage the USFS to address high priority invasive species, pests, and diseases, including the emerald ash borer, an unspecified “bark beetle”, spotted lanternfly, and Spruce Budworm. The list also includes three invasive plant species: buckthorn, Amur honeysuckle, and Callery pear. This language is not tied to a specific program, so it is unclear what will actually result.

In the R&D section of the report, the Committee “recognizes the significant damage invasive species can cause throughout forests, including urban forests, and encourages the USFS to continue reforestation efforts, including through the management of woody invasive species & tree planting in urban areas.” Again, the wording seems somewhat misplaced since the R&D program does not carry out tree planting.

State, Private, and Tribal forests

I had asked the Interior Appropriations Subcommittee to maintain funding for State, Private, and Tribal forests program at the FY26 Continuing Resolution level of $310.6 million. Again, appropriators ignored the Administration’s request and provided $283,500,000 – a fairly small reduction. The Forest Health Management program was funded at $58 – of which $16 million is specified for efforts on federal lands, $42 million for helping state and tribal agencies and private landowners to manage pests on their lands.

The Subcommittee report emphasized the importance of working with Colorado to curtail spread of mountain pine beetle d associated wildfire risk. Music to my ears is the Committee’s statement encouraging the USFS to work with state & local agencies to counter the high rate of tree mortality due to the goldspotted oak borer infestation in Southern California. It advised prioritizing insect research, prevention, suppression, & mitigation projects that support community wildfire protection & State forest action plans. Since none of the members of the House Interior Appropriations Subcommittee is from California, I am pleasantly puzzled.

coast live oak (Quercus agrifolia) killed by goldspotted oak borer; Heisey County Park, San Diego County, California. Photo by F.T. Campbell

The Interior Appropriations Subcommittee expressed continued concern about poor regeneration of eastern white oak (Quercus alba). (Of course, several other tree species are also regenerating poorly but a strong lobby is tied to oaks due to their economic importance.

i’iwi – a formerly common Hawaiian honeycreeper badly suppressed by avian malaria; photo by by James Petruzzi

Hawaii’s endangered birds

I am very pleased that the House Interior Appropriations Committee has provided $1,250,000 is for continuing research to protect Hawaiian forest birds from the dire extinction threat arising from non-native mosquitoes carrying avian malaria & other pathogens.

USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service

APHIS is responsible for preventing the introduction and spread of pests and invasive plants that harm agriculture, including forests. APHIS policy guides port inspections carried out by the DHS CBP. APHIS inspects imported live plants. Unlike the USFS, APHIS has the support of the Trump Administration, so funding levels have remained steady. Of course, continuing introductions of new pests and spread of established ones – and inflation – have increased the cost of countering invasions, so the agency continues to fall behind despite its relatively privileged position.

The House of Representatives adopted the FY27 Agriculture Appropriations Bill in early June. I apologize for the obscurity of the FY26 funding levels. Figures are in millions of dollars.

FY2025 enacted                        FY27

APHIS total                                $1,148                                      $1,157

Plant health subtotal               $387.5                                      $387.6             

Agric. quarantine                      $35.5                                        $35.5

Field crop and rangeland           $12                                           $10

Pest detection                           $29                                           $29

Methods development               $21.5                                        $21

Specialty crops                          $206.5                                      $209

Tree and wood pests                  $59                                           $58.6

In its report, the Subcommittee on Agriculture Appropriations did not express concern about the issues that I had raised in my testimony. Instead, it mentioned several agricultural pests, e.g., citrus greening, fruit flies, a non-native beetle threatening nut orchards, and spotted lanternfly (Lycorma delicatula). The Subcommittee also urged APHIS to work with the USDA Forest Service to counter the spread of two native wood-borers, mountain pine beetle (Dendroctonus ponderosae) in Colorado and southern pine beetle (Dendroctonus frontalis). Since both are native, APHIS’ role is unclear. The Subcommittee mentioned two invasive plants: glossy buckthorn (Frangula alnus) – saying it threatens biodiversity, especially in the Allegheny National Forest in Pennsylvania; and Carizzo cane (Arundo donax), saying it contributes to tick invasions in addition to hampering detection of human immigrants along the Rio Grande.

sounder graphic by Jack Mayer, Savannah River National Laboratory

The bill increases funding for the national feral swine management program by $500,000. (I cannot determine total the appropriation). The Agriculture Appropriations Subcommittee had urged APHIS Wildlife Services to prioritize states with the largest invasive populations – although this choice contradicts standard advice for managing invasive species, including feral swine.

In one action linked to our concerns about wood-borer introductions via wood packaging, the Subcommittee encouraged APHIS to recognize sulfuryl fluoride as a treatment for logs, wood products, & wood packaging. This fumigant has been accepted under the international (ISPM#15) since 2013.

wooden pallets discarded next to wooded border in Glacier National Park, Montana; photo by F.T. Campbell

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

US imports continue falling … expected to sink further in 2026

Kevin Saville reports for the Journal of Commerce that containerized imports in 2025 are expected to be only 25.2 million TEUs, a decrease of 1.4% from 2024.

Declines are particularly large in the final months of 2025 since importers frontloaded their purchases to try to get ahead of the Trump Administration’s new tariffs. Imports for the first half of the year were up 3.6% compared with 2024 at 12.53 million TEUs. Thus, Saville’s sources expect November import levels to be 11.6% lower than in November 2024; December’s to be almost 13% lower.

Analysts expect the steeper decline to continue into the new year. Ben Hackett, of Hackett Associates, expects import volumes in the first four months of 2026 to be 10.3%, 8.5%, 16.8% , and 11% lower than the corresponding months a year earlier. The data source covers the ports of Los Angeles/Long Beach, Oakland, & Seattle & Tacoma on the West Coast; New York/New Jersey, the Port of Virginia, Charleston, Savannah, Port Everglades, Miami & Jacksonville on the East Coast; & Houston on the Gulf Coast. These are not all the maritime ports, but they are the major ones.

Another JOC reporter, Michael Angell, quoted several sources as saying they expect import volumes for all of 2026 to be flat or down 2% from 2025. Illustrating the reversal from past trends, The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey expects total container volumes in 2026 to be 8.5 million TEUs, a decline of about 2% from 2024. Since 2016, NY-NJ port container volumes have grown at an annual average of 4.2%.

As I have blogged before — see here and here — these swings in import volumes threaten to undermine programs intended to prevent introductions of wood-boring insects hitching rides in wood packaging material. While the higher volumes arriving from Asia in the first half of 2025 pose the most obvious risk, falling volumes reduce fee-based funding that support port inspectors. Another factor is the shift to suppliers other than China – primarily countries in Southeast Asia. Two beneficiaries of this shift are Vietnam and – at least initially – India. They have much better records of compliance with ISPM#15-mandated treatments for wood packaging link than does China.

A third JOC source reports that while US and European imports are down, trade volumes in Asia, Africa, the Middle East and Latin America are rising. I expect this growing trade to facilitate new pest introductions, although we will have to wait several years to see any data.  

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

New Sirex established in South America … threat to pine plantations + threat to native conifer from North American aphid

pine plantation near Buenos Aires; photo by Biologicadero via Wikimedia

I have learned about the introduction of a North American woodwasp, Sirex obesus, in Brazil. Forestry interests in South America are worried that this woodwasp will cause significant damage to the pine plantations occupying 4.6 million hectares on the continent.

In July 2023, experts at the Estação Experimental de Ciências Florestais at ESALQ/USP in Itatinga, São Paulo, Brazil, investigated dead and symptomatic trees of several Pinus species and subspecies. They expected the causal agent to be Sirex noctilio – a woodwasp native to Europe and North Africa that has caused considerable damage to South American pine plantations since the 1980s (Wilcken et al.).

However, the pine species attacked were not typical hosts for S. noctilio (in Brazil, loblolly pine Pinus taeda). Instead, the infected trees were Caribbean pines, i.e., Pinus caribaea hondurensis, P. caribaea bahamensis, P. caribaea caribaea, P. maximinoi, P. tecunumani. The responsible woodwasp was identified as Sirex obesus. This species is native to the southwestern United States and northern and central Mexico (Wilcken et al.). This species is closely related to S. californicus (Wilcken et al.).

A second outbreak was found in November ~ 130 km away (still in São Paulo state). Scientists have not determined whether the two São Paulo outbreaks are related. Dr. Villacide reports (pers. comm.) that the two populations genetics have been compared, but he does not have the results.

A third population has been detected in a second, neighboring, state, Minas Gerais (Wilcken to Lantschner and Villacide).

Dr. Villacide (pers. comm.) reports that Brazilian scientists are trying to delimit the extent of the outbreaks. Public and private scientists in other countries with pine plantations have begun developing responses.

This is the first record of S. obesus outside of North America (Wilckens et al.).

Little is known yet about this woodwasp’s probable impact. It is clear that it can oviposit in a wide range of pines. In its native range, S. obesus has been reported on three host species: Pinus ponderosa, P. teocote (twisted-leaf pine), and P. leiophylla (no common name; native to Chihuahua – mostly in Mexico, and border areas of New Mexico and Arizona]. In Brazil, as noted, it has been recorded on other species as well as the hybrids P. caribaea x P. elliottii and P. caribaea x P. tecunumanii (Wilcken et al.).

So for purposes of their risk assessment, Lantschner and Villacide assumed that S. obesus can affect any of the species commonly planted in the region: P. taeda, P. elliottii, P. ponderosa, P. contorta, P. caribaea, P. oocarpa, P. patula, P. radiata, and P. tecunumanii (Lantschner and Villacide).

The risk assessment predicts suitable climatic conditions for invasion by S. obesus in 48% of the areas where South American pine plantation occur, particularly in montane and high-altitude regions along the Andean corridor and central-eastern Brazil. Incorporating other factors – host distribution, proximity to invaded areas, and volume of wood imports from Brazil – identified the most vulnerable areas as in southern Brazil, northeast Argentina, the Argentine Patagonia, and central Chile (Lantschner and Villacide).

pine plantation in Argentina; photo by Tomas Asurmendi via pexels

Preliminary sampling (Wilcken et al.) indicates the impacts could be severe. Mortality varies by species: in the worst cases average mortality approached 43% on P. caribaea hondurensis but only 11% on loblolly pine (P. taeda). They expect mortality rates to increase. Another 30% of P.c. hondurensis trees are dripping resin, a sign of woodwasp oviposition. If these eggs hatch, those larvae will probably kill the affected trees. Such a result would increase total mortality of P.c. hondurensis from 43% to ~ 73%. For P. taeda, the current mortality rate of 11% could rise to 49% as an additional 38% of trees succumb. Following this logic, these areas could experience complete tree mortality within a few years. Given the extent of pine plantations, and possible mortality rates, even a partial spread of S. obesus could lead to significant econ losses.

As second factor is the number of generations per year; the higher the number, the faster woodwasp populations can increase. Wilckens et al. report that adult emergence in Pinus logs maintained in cages indicates that S. obesus could have two or three generations per year.

S. obesus seems to prefer a different climate than S. noctilio. As noted, S. obesus seems to prefer montane and high-altitude climates. S. noctilio is concentrated in lowland temperate and humid regions (Lantschner and Villacide). The newly introduced species might substantially broaden the geographic area where pine plantations might be at risk – although further research is needed to clarify this point.

S. obesus also appears to be spreading at a rapid rate — ~46 km / year. At this rate, Lantschner and Villacide say it could spread throughout all major pine plantation areas in Brazil in less than years.

Sirex woodwasps kill trees by injecting a symbiotic wood decay fungus and a phytotoxic mucus into the tree when ovipositing. The toxin weakens the tree, allowing the fungus to spread, typically killing the tree in as little as three–four months. In North America S. obesus is associated with Amylostereum chailletti. While this species has not yet been confirmed in Brazil, (Wilckens et al.). Brazilian scientists are exploring whether S. obesus might adopt the fungus already present, Amylostereum areolatum, which is associated with S. noctilio.

Two insect species known to feed on woodwasps have emerged from logs infested with S. obesus: Ibalia leucospoides (Hymenoptera: Ibaliidae) and a species of Schlettererius (Hymenoptera: Stephanidae). While these two predators have not proved to be effective controls of woodwasps by themselves, they might become part of a control program. The parasitic nematode, Deladenus siricidicola (Nematoda: Neotylenchidae) used successfully in several South Hemisphere countries to control S. noctilio has not been found in Brazil (Wilckens et al.).

Scientists don’t know the pathway by which S. obesus entered Brazil. Wilckens believes it was via wood packaging; technicians from the Ministry of Agriculture have found some pallets associated with imports that lacked the ISPM#15 mark (Wilckens et al.).

Both Lantschner and Villacide and Wilcken et al. stress the vulnerability of South American pine plantations to introduction of damaging pests. The plantations are reportedly intensively managed, even-aged, regularly spaced monocultures. These conditions can facilitate invasive species establishment and spread by providing abundant host resources and reduced natural enemy pressure. Lantschner and Villacide cite Michael Wingfield that in plantation forestry, introduction of a single pest species can damage large areas of valuable timber.

mortality caused by Sirex noctilio in a pine plantation in Argentina; photo courtesy of Jose Villacide

The family Siricidae contains more than 120 species distributed across the forests of the Northern Hemisphere. In their native ranges they are typically minor or secondary pests (Wilckens et al.). Woodwasps have demonstrated that they can be transported in international commerce – S. noctilio alone has invaded pine stands (native or exotic) in nine countries in Oceania, Africa, and South and North America. Three other species in the family — Urocerus gigas, Urocerus flavicornis and Tremex fuscicornis – have been detected in South America (Wilckens et al.). If each represents a unique threat, countries with widespread pine plantations should enhance their phytosanitary programs. Exporting parties, e.g., the United States and European Union, should assist in efforts to prevent spread of these wood borers. One major step would be to strengthen regulations governing wood packaging material. [To see my criticisms of shortfalls of the ISPM#15 system, scroll down the list of blogs to “Categories” and click on “wood packaging”.]

Lantschner and Villacide cautionthat their assessment is based on a limited record of S. obesus occurrences in its native range. This range might be restricted by factors other than climate, including geographic barriers or biotic interactions (natural enemy pressure or interspecific competition). If so, the species’ potential invasive range might be larger than the climate-based models predict.

Recommendations for management strategies

I applaud Lantschner and Villacide for proposing immediate steps to improve management of the threat posed by introduction of S. obesus. These recommendations should prioritize enhanced phytosanitary inspections of wood products moving between high-risk regions and other South American countries. They suggest that Brazil adopt bilateral agreements with its major trading partners which would specify protocols for woodwaspdetection and quarantines. [Since many of these countries already have established populations of S. noctilio they probably do not have strong phytosanitary measures targeting wood borers at present.] Lantschner and Villacide advise creation of targeted surveillance programs in southern Brazil, northeastern Argentina, Argentine Patagonia, and central Chile. They should focus on sites near major transportation hubs and border crossings. Less intense surveillance should be instituted in regions they classified as medium risk. Again, the focus should be on major points of entry for imported goods and on plantations located near the Brazilian border. They note that preventing spread of S. obesus into new areas will require not only national efforts but also regionally coordinated monitoring, research, and forest health policies.

Lantschner and Villacide also identify priority areas for future research. These include clarifying S. obesus’shost range, the environmental conditions that enable the woodwasp to establish and persist beyond its native range, dispersal rates, and whether S. obesus exhibits pulse-like pop dynamics[long periods of low density interrupted by sudden outbreaks] seen in S. noctilio.

Dr. Villacide (pers. comm.) reports that Brazilian scientists are trying to delimit the extent of the outbreaks. Public and private scientists in other countries with pine plantations have begun developing responses. Dr. Villacide has posted a video from a recent online seminar sponsored by the Southern Cone Forest Health Group. Go to https://youtu.be/uVU6CpFNhlQ?si=lqXtwJTtz5rKXfL3 or
https://sanidadforestalconosur.org/

A wider prespective

Dr. Villacide’s attention to Sirex obesus is part of his broader work on pest issues in South America’s commercial plantations. In another publication (Villacide and Fuetealba 2025; full citation at the end of this blog), he explores how to make these plantations sustainable in the face of rising threats from pests – both introduced and native to the region. Dr. Villacide and Alvaro Fuetealba report that every year 1.2 million hectares of plantations in the Southern Cone are affected by pests. Their vulnerability of will be worsened by the extreme weather events expected under climate change.  

These plantations present vast areas of homogeneous stands: ~97% of the Southern Cone planted area consists of exotic tree species – mainly Pinus and Eucalyptus. Typical plantations are high density and managed intensively – including thinning, pruning, and fertilizing – to prompt rapid growth. As Villacide and Fuetealba point out, while these practices maximize wood production efficiency, they also lead to biological homogenization and reduced resilience to pests.

They report that pine plantations are under attack by wood and bark borers that have followed pines to the region, including Sirex noctilio, Orthotomicus erosus, and Cyrtogenius luteus; and now the newly detected Sirex obesus (above). At least two fungal pathogens — Fusarium circinatum and Dothistroma septosporum – have also been introduced. The principal threat to pine plantations from native pests comes from leaf-cutting ants (Atta and Acromyrmex).Eucalyptus plantations are plagued by several insects that have arrived from Australia, including Phoracantha semipunctata, Thaumastocoris peregrinus, and Leptocybe invasa. Pests native to the region that attack Eucalyptus are the Chilean carpenter worm (Chilecomadia valdiviana) and the leaf-cutting ants.

Cordilleran cypress; photo by LBM 1948 via Wikimedia

Threat to native conifer

More worrying to me is that introduced pests have entered native forests. Villacide and Fuetealba report that the aphid Cinara cupressi is attacking the native conifer Austrocedrus chilensis. Cordilleran cypress, also called Chilean or Patagonian cedar, is an endemic, monospecific tree in the Cupressaceae family. In southern Argentina and Chile the species forms pure and mixed stands with southern hemisphere beech (Nothofagus spp.) across ~ 160,000 ha. The profile Cinara cupressi on the Global Invasive Species Database is unclear about how many species are in the species complex and their places of origin.

Cordilleran cypress is also under attack by the oomycete Phytophthora austrocedri, an oomycete of unknown origin. This pathogen is of unknown origin. It is now thought to have been present in Argentina since at least the 1960s. P. austrocedri has also been ntroduced to Europe, western Asia, and North America.

Villacide and Fuetealba advocate several actions to might diversify tree species in the plantations to reduce their vulnerability to pests. They note that this recommendation builds on foundational ecological theory, including the resource concentration and natural enemy hypotheses. Diversity-promoting actions should reach beyond any plantation to the landscape level. Managers should consider connectivity of susceptible stands, the number of nutritionally optimal host trees in the landscape, and the availability and quality of hosts in adjacent stands.

Villacide and Fuetealba say mixed plantations can provide additional ecological and economic benefits, such as enhanced stand-level productivity; production of a wider range of commercial and subsistence products; and greater resistance and resilience to natural disturbances, e.g., extreme weather events.

They warn that designing and implementing mixed plantations must reflect ecological interactions and pest dynamics as well as management. There is need for regionally coordinated experimental plantations where scientist could test how variables such as tree species composition, density and spatial arrangement, and silvicultural practices influence pest dynamics, forest productivity, and ecosystem resilience under local conditions. They suggest incorporating sentinel plantings both early-warning systems and decision-support tools at plot and regional scales. Researchers should evaluate pest-specific responses, productivity trade-offs, long-term forest health outcomes under different scenarios.

Since the plantations extend across a multinational region with few natural barriers and uniform silvicultural practices, as well as high levels of trade, so do the pest problems. Therefore, the response must also be regional – e.g., regional experimental plantations and living laboratories. A collaborative approach linking researchers, forest managers, and policymakers is essential to translate experimental findings into practice and develop adaptive, ecol grounded silvicultural strategies. Long-term ecological trials must be embedded in operational contexts and aligned across countries.

SOURCES

Lantschner, V. and J. Villacide. 2025. Invasion Potential of the Recently Established Woodwasp Sirex obesus. Neotropical Entomology. (2025) 54:117  https://doi.org/10.1007/s13744-025-01347-6

Villacide, J. and A. Fuetealba. 2025. Pests in plantations: Challenging traditional productive paradigms in the Southern Cone of America. Forest Ecology and Management 597 (2025) 123127

Wilcken, C.F., T.A. da Mota, C.H. de Oliveir, V.R. de Carvalho, L.A. Benso, J.A. Gabia, S.R.S. Wilcken, E.L. Furtado, N.M. Schiff, M.B. de Camargo, M.F. Ribeiro. 2025. Sirex obesus (Hymenoptera: Siricidae) as invasive pest in pine plantations in Brazil. Scientific Reports. 2025. 15:22522  https://doi.org/10.1038/541598-025-06418-7

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org