While Michiganders document the impacts of the emerald ash borer (EAB) there, conservationists on the West Coast are jump-starting efforts to save their regional species, Oregon ash (Fraxinus latifolia). Earlier field tests in the Midwest showed that EAB will attack Oregon ash (press release) – something West Coast state would like to counter as early and effectively as possible.
Oregon ash is a wide-ranging species, occurring from California to Washington and possibly into British Columbia. The species has not been studied extensively (it is not a timber species!), but it is clearly an imponearlrtant component of riparian forests. In wetter parts of the Willamette Valley, ash is the predominant tree species. See the photo of the riparian forest in the Ankeny National Wildlife Refuge; this forest is nearly 100% Oregon ash (ODA/ODF EAB Response Plan).
As is true in the Midwest, ash provides important food and habitat resources along creeks and rivers where seasonally high water-tables can exclude nearly all other tree species. Standing and fallen dead ash biomass can alter soil chemistry and affect rates of decomposition, nutrient, and water cycling, i.e., nutrient resource availability for the remaining trees. Gaps in tree canopy can increase soil erosion, stormwater runoff and elevated stream temperatures. In dense stands of Oregon ash, understory vegetation is often sparse, consisting primarily of sedges. The authors of the Response Plan anticipate invasion by non-native plants into canopy gaps caused by the loss of ash trees as a result of an EAB invasion. In Michigan, though, it is the sedges that dominate these gaps.
The Oregon Department of Forestry, the state Department of Agriculture, and other entities have actively participated in “don’t move firewood” campaigns for at least a decade. The Departments of Forestry and Agriculture also led a team that prepared the EAB Response Plan in 2018 (full citation at the end of this blog). It lays out in considerable detail the roles of both government agencies and non-governmental stakeholders. Oregon’s quarantine is broad, covering all insects not on an approved list (Williams, pers. comm.)
California has inspected incoming firewood for years. In April 2021 – after APHIS terminated the federal quarantine on EAB — California Department of Food and Agriculture established a state quarantine on the beetle and articles that could transport it into the state. In doing so, CDFA noted that commercially grown olive trees might also be at risk to EAB.
Washington State operates a statewide trapping program for invasive insects. There has also been significant attention to non-native insect threats to urban forests. These have included a study in 2016 led by the Washington Invasive Species Council (WISC). It involved a partnership of WISC with the Washington Department of Natural Resources Urban and Community Forestry Program as well as and statewide stakeholder meetings [Bush, pers. comm.].
Of these various state-wide initiatives, the institutions in Oregon appear to be most pro-active. The Tualatin Soil and Water Conservation District provided $10,000 to fund some of the genetics work and testing for EAB resistance. Other funding came from the USDA Forest Service Forest Health Protection unit of State and Private Forestry (not from USFS’ Research Program). As described by USFS geneticist Richard Sneizko in an article in the publication TreeLine (full citation at end of blog), participants hope to find at least some level of genetic resistance to EAB. Any such resistance might be deployed in several ways: 1) promoting reproduction by resistant trees to enhance their numbers before EAB gets to Oregon; 2) using seeds from resistant trees for restoration of natural areas; or 3) cross-breeding resistant trees to build genetically diverse stocks of resistant trees for future restoration.
Participants think it is vitally important to work from seeds collected over much of the range of Oregon ash – first, to search for probably very rare resistant trees; and second, to preserve the full diversity of the tree species’ genome so that restored ash will be adapted to the wide variety of conditions in which ash grow.
Participants in this effort include the forest genetics/tree improvement community – specifically, the USDA Forest Service Dorena Genetic Resource Center (located in Cottage Grove, Oregon) and Washington State University at Puyallup Research & Extension Center. Also engaged is the public gardens community, specifically the Huntington Botanical Gardens in San Marino, Los Angeles County. The garden is collecting seed of Oregon and other western ashes from California and Washington State.
The first step in assessing resistance is collecting seed from ash trees across the range of Oregon ash. This began in 2019. Carried out by, inter alia, some USFS and Interior’s Bureau of Land Management units, Oregon State University, citizen scientists [Sniezko] and the Oregon Department of Forestry [press release & Sniezko pers. comm.] Also, some seeds were collected in Washington State in 2020. Additional collections in Oregon are scheduled for 2022.
The collected seeds have been evaluated for vitality and stored by the USFS Dorena Center and at the USFS National Seed Lab (Macon, GA).
The USFS Dorena Center and Washington State University have begun germinating and growing some of the seedlings for various tests of possible resistance. There is concern that the 2021 drought might have killed some of the seedlings in Oregon; those in Washington are not affected. The initial seedlings are mostly from Oregon but there is space to add additional families from a wider geographical area. Experimenters plan to collect data annually on bud break, yearly growth, and any diseases or pests that develop on the trees. (Chastagner pers. comm.)
The next step is systematic testing whether some of the ash show genetic resistance to EAB. Richard Sneizko has sent seedlings of 17 ash families to USFS colleague Dr. Jennifer Koch. She operates a breeding facility in northern Ohio where they can be tested for resistance. Testing is expected to begin this year. [Tree Line]
The Dorena Center is also helping a researcher at Penn State University, Dr. Jill Hamilton, to set up a landscape genomics project. She will evaluate the genetic variability in the species by using leaf samples from about 20 trees from many populations across the Oregon ash’s range (California to British Columbia). This potentially includes a collection from the Dorena population of ash in late Spring 2022. [Sniezko]
These various ash plantings can also be “sentinel” plantings to assist in early detection of newly arriving EAB. [Tree Line]
SOURCES
Bush J. Executive Coordinator | Washington Invasive Species Council
ODF and ODA Emerald Ash Borer Readiness and Response Plan. 2018.
ODF press release Feb 24, 2022
Treeline Newsletter May 13, 2021. Richard Sniezko. Is There a Future for Oregon Ash? Forest Genetics to the Rescue? Genetic & Emerald Ash Borer Resistance Projects https://www.nnrg.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Treeline_newsletter-June-2021.pdf
The newsletter is issued by Bonneville Environmental Foundation for a consortium of conservation agencies
Sniezko pers comm Feb 2022 22-2/24
A video explaining the campaign to save Oregon ash is at https://youtu.be/uZmfLrxEA7g or https://youtu.be/S8y-XK285S8
Posted by Faith Campbell
We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.
For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm