Invasive plants threaten integrity of eastern U.S. forests

garlic mustard (Alliaria petiolata); photo by Katja Schulz via Wikimedia

I welcome a recent series of studies documenting the extent of plant invasions in forests of the eastern United States and the socio-economic conditions that contribute to a state of affairs increasingly recognized as a crisis. I wish, however, that the authors had devoted more attention to the role of deliberate planting of non-native species and the resulting propagule pressure.

I summarize here findings of two studies written by largely the same scientists and relying on the same underlying data: surveys of forest plots conducted under the Forest Inventory and Analysis (FIA) program. In this blog, if focus on the extent of invasive plant presence in the forests of the eastern United States. In an accompanying blog I will summarize the status of plant invasions in forests nation-wide.

As I have noted in earlier blogs, link a decade ago one or more invasive plant species had already invaded 46% of FIA plots in the eastern U.S. (Oswald et al. 2015). This situation has worsened. Updated data show that 52.8% of these plots contain invasive plants. In the USFS Southern Region, invasive plants have been documented on 55.3 million ha. In the Northern Region, they are found on 36.9 million ha. (Only ~20% of FIA plots in the Northern Region were surveyed for invasive plants.) In some counties of the 37 states constituting these two USFS regions, 80% of inventoried forest plots contain invasive plants. Areas with lower levels of invasion are found in parts of New England, the Great Lakes states, southern Appalachians, southeastern coastal plain, and western Texas and Oklahoma (Potter et al. 2026). Spread of these bioinvaders is largely unchecked – either throughout the East or “just” in the South. In any case, the extent and intensity of these invasions are so great that their complete removal – or elimination of their impacts – is “practically impossible” (Potter et al., 2024; Potter et al. 2026). [It is not clear whether the scientists mean “nearly” or “in practice”. Or that this difference is important.]

[In comparison, in the West less than 30% of FIA plots are invaded, on average. In Hawai`i, more than70% are (Potter et al. 2026).]

The scientists analyzing the FIA data warn that the extent and impact of plant invasions in eastern forests is undoubtedly worse than these data indicate. The records include only some of the non-native plant species present — those considered to be the worst invaders at the time regional lists were compiled – apparently in the first years of the 21st Century (Potter et al. 2026).

Japanese honeysuckle (Lonicera japonica) photo by Chuck Bargeron

The scientists emphasize the role of disturbance in promoting plant invasions. They cite various studies as well as the FIA data to document that forest edges facilitate non-native plant establishment and spread into forests. They stress various aspects of suburban development, including roads and other transportation corridors. It follows that invasion rates are highest in the “wildland-urban interface (WUI).” [The wildlife-urban interface is the zone of transition between unoccupied land and human development; the zone where structures meet or intermix with undeveloped land and its vegetation.] They worry that the WUI is growing faster than any other land use type in the country – and especially rapidly in the East. As a result, the scientists expect more and worse invasions in the future (Potter et al., 2024 and Potter et al. 2026).

I appreciate that they highlight the uniqueness of WUI ecosystems. Housing development in the WUI has numerous effects on natural ecosystems, including habitat modification and fragmentation followed by diffusion of the direct and indirect effects of anthropogenic activities into neighboring ecosystems at different scales. As regards specifically non-native plants, this transmission occurs through a combination of (1) human-driven disturbances to native ecosystems that promote plant invasion and (2) providing a source of non-native plant propagules in their yards and gardens. These plants can then spread into and establish in nearby ecosystems (in this case, forests). [I note that tree-killing arthropods and pathogens also can be introduced in the WUI.] (Scroll below “Archives” to “Categories”, click on “forest pests” and “wood packaging”.)

They also found that plant invasions are more strongly related to older, than more recent, land-cover changes. Survey plots that have been located in the WUI since 1990 or earlier had on average 2.6% more invasive plant cover and 0.33 more invasive plant species than those that were classified as being in the WUI in 2000 or 2010. Their explanation is that the WUI forests experienced decreased spatial integrity, increased forest-developed area edges, and falling proportions of forest in the surrounding landscapes. In addition, the human population in the vicinity might have grown. All these factors that would increase forest fragmentation and the plots’ susceptibility to invasion.

The other side of the coin is propagule pressure. Both Potter et al (2024) and Potter et al. (2026) note that the flora of residential landscapes – rural as well as suburban – is typically dominated by non-native plant species. Still, I think these studies downplay the impact of this ubiquity of non-native plants in all anthropogenic landscapes.

In discussing the higher invasion rates found in survey plots located in WUIs dating from the 1990s they made no mention of human activities that promote plant invasions. There are several. Plants growing in those older yards had one or two more decades to flower – and for their fruits and seeds to be transported into the forest by birds, wind, or water. Residents might have decided to beautify their neighborhood by planting shrubs or flowers in the woods. Maybe they succumbed to the temptation to dump yard waste in the woods – thinking it would be absorbed by “nature”. Since plant invasions take time to unfold, these additional years of human-mediated exposure are highly relevant. Another factor is that people who choose to live in wooded surroundings probably choose horticultural plants that thrive under such conditions – exactly those best able to establish beyond the property line.

Another opportunity to discuss these factors came from the discovery that plant invasion rates are higher in association with “interface” rather than “intermix” WUI forests. [“WUI interface forests” are those where settled areas abut wildlands. In “WUI intermix forests” the structures are scattered.] They speculate about reasons. Potter, et al. (2024) mention that invasions originating from older housing developments have had more time to establish (or at least to be detected) given the well-known lag associated with plant invasions.

I wish they had focused more on the probable difference in suburban development across time. While I was growing up in expanding suburbs in the 1950s, I observed that the earlier housing developments were either built on land that had been cleared to support agriculture or the builders cleared the forest to make construction easier and cheaper. More recently, wealthier buyers have sought residences on more wooded sites – so creating an “intermix” WUI. Potter et al. (2024) speculate that locations in the “interface” WUI are closer to high-density urbanization so have higher exposure to non-native plants. They do not discuss whether the “interface” WUIs are older, thus giving associated plantings longer years to proceed through the stages of bioinvasion.

burning bush (Euonymus alatus) invading a forest in Virginia; photo by F.T. Campbell

The Role of Deliberate Planting?

I recognize that these authors analyzed mountains of data. However, I wish they had incorporated the findings of numerous scientists who have analyzed the role of deliberate planting – especially ornamental horticulture – in facilitating introduction and spread of invasive plants. (Scroll below “Archives” to “Categories” and click on “invasive plants”. Also See Reichard and White 2001 and Mack 2000).

As I hope USFS scientists are aware, recent studies confirm the continuing role of ornamental horticulture in plant invasions. Kinlock et al. (2025) blog 440 found that more than 1,600 plant species sold by nursery and seed catalogs over 200 years had “naturalized” somewhere in the continental 48 states. They do not discuss what proportion of these species are truly damaging invaders. Fertakos and Bradley (2024) found that species were likely to establish if they were introduced to as few as eight locations. Beaury et al. (2024) found that half of 89 plant species recognized as invasive are sold in the same locations where they are invasive. Another 25 species are sold by one or more nurseries located in an area that is currently unsuitable for those species, but that will become more suitable for invasion as temperatures warm.

Potter et al. (2026) acknowledge that the ornamental plant trade is likely to continue introducing new plant species into U.S. forests. However, they recommend only updating the lists of invasive plants to be included in future surveys. Apparently these lists have not been updated since 2004.

Potter et al. (2024) go farther, urging efforts to encourage homeowners to plant more native and environmentally friendly private landscapes. They note that such advocacy is complicated by the fact that non-native – even invasive – species provide valued ecosystem and cultural services.

I add that the nursery industry and their customers enjoy enormous lobbying clout.

Many associations – native plant societies, regional or state invasive plant councils, etc. – are pursuing this approach. To research these efforts, visit the websites for the state native plant societies and the Southeast Exotic Pest Plant Council, Mid-Atlantic Invasive Plant Council, and Midwest Invasive Plant Network. These voluntary efforts have yielded some success. But they have not resulted in adequate protection for our ecosystems. Dr. Douglas Tallamy points out that even non-invasive, non-native plants disrupt food webs.

The insufficient attention to the role of the plant trade in articles intended to be comprehensive has crucially important impacts. As both Potter, et al. (2024) and Potter et al. (2026) affirm, determining which factors are most important in facilitating plant invasions of eastern American forests is the necessary foundation for identifying and implementing the most efficient and effective counter measures.

These scientists are employees of the U.S. Department of Agriculture. If departmental leadership interpret their studies as justifying inaction on regulating plant sales, USDA’s regulatory agencies will not respond. And we will continue failing to curtail introduction and spread of damaging plant invasions.

I agree with the authors on the need for enhanced monitoring and management of WUI zones in the East to detect new species or new locations of invasion and the need to develop better tools for these purposes. However, I ask all stakeholders to follow Evans et al. (2024), who urge prioritizing for state regulation those species in the ornamental trade that are projected to remain or become abundant under evolving climate conditions. Or, more aggressively, follow Beaury et al. (2023)’s call for regulating the nursery trade in a manner consistent with the scope of the horticultural trade at the national level. That would require legislation, since the Federal Noxious Weed Act does not currently address long-established, widespread species. Beaury et al. (2023) also note that existing state restrictions are outdated, tend to include only a few weeds that plague agriculture rather than those that invade natural systems, and are irregularly enforced.

orchids in Everglades National Park; photo by F.T. Campbell

I conclude by agreeing with the scientists that managing the disturbance component of plant invasions points to protecting particularly forests of high conservation value. They suggest adoption of land-use planning rules aimed at this goal. However, as they point out, such action will be extremely unlikely given the magnitude of predicted land-use changes in the country and powerful demographic factors driving them. I would add other barriers: the lobbying clout of the real estate industry and homeowners plus the local nature of zoning decisions.

SOURCES

Beaury, E.M., J.M. Allen, A.E. Evans, M.E. Fertakos, W.G. Pfadenhauer, B.A. Bradley. 2023. Horticulture could facilitate invasive plant range infilling and range expansion with climate change. BioScience 2023 0 1-8 https://doi.org/10.1093/biosci/biad069

Evans, A.E., C.S. Jarnevich, E.M. Beaury, P.S. Engelstad, N.B. Teich, J.M. LaRoe, B.A. Bradley. 2024. Shifting hotspots: Climate change projected to drive contractions and expansions of invasive plant abundance habitats. Diversity and Distributions 2024;30:4154

Fertakos, M.E. and B.A. Bradley. 2024. Propagule pressure from historic U.S. plant sales explains establishment but not invasion. Ecology Letters 2024;27:e14494  doi: 10.1111/ele.14494

Kinlock, N.L., D.W. Adams, W. Dawson, F. Essl, J. Kartesz, H. Kreft, M. Nishino, Jan Pergl, P. Pyšek, P. Weigelt and M. van Kleunen. 2025. Naturalization of ornamental plants in the United States depends on cultivation and historical land cover context. Ecography 2025: e07748 doi: 10.1002/ecog.07748

Oswalt, C.M., S. Fei, Q. Guo, B.V. Iannone III, S.N. Oswalt, B.C. Pijanowski, K.M. Potter. 2016. A subcontinental view of forest plant invasions. NeoBiota. 24:49-54 http://www.srs.fs.usda.gov/pubs/48489

Potter, K.M., K.H. Riitters, B.V. Iannone III, Q. Guo and S. Fei. 2024. Forest plant invasions in the eastern United States: evidence of invasion debt in the wildland‑urban interface. Landsc Ecol (2024) 39:207 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10980-024-01985-y

Potter, K.M., B.V. Iannone III, K.H. Riitters, Q. Guo, K. Pandit, C.M. Oswalt. 2026. US Forests are Increasingly Invaded by Problematic Non-Native Plants. Forest Ecology and Management 599 (2026) 123281

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

Pest Threats to Plantations: Will At-Risk Countries Demand Improvements to IPPC?

pines in a plantation in Argentina killed by Sirex noctilio; photo by J. Villacide

 A decade ago, Payn et al. (2015) compiled studies from around the globe to evaluate threats to widespread tree plantations. At that time, they said climate change posed the greatest threat to plantation forestry globally, in the forms of storm and flood damage and simultaneous warming and drying trends with extreme temperatures.

Still, the authors warned that forest health would be an increasingly important constraint to plantation productivity. They were optimistic, however, that modern breeding and other technologies could offset losses.

What is the current situation? The countries that depend on these plantations for fiber production are not demanding that leaders of the international phytosanitary structure build a more effective system to protect their investments. Instead, individual scientists struggle to better understand threats. Mostly, they propose expanded research.

Economic Importance of these Species

Eucalypts

“Eucalypts” comprises three genera in the family Myrtaceae: Angophora, Corymbia and Eucalyptus. These include more than 700 tree species native primarily to Australia. A few species are native to Indonesia, New Guinea and the Philippines (Paine et al. 2011; Crous et al. 2019). Some of these species have been extensively planted outside their native ranges for more than 100 years. These plantations have expanded rapidly in recent decades, especially in Southeast Asia and the Southern Hemisphere (Crous et al. 2019). Eucalypts are now the most widely planted hardwood timber in the world (Paine et al. 2011).

Eucalypt plantation in Brazil; photo by Jonathan Wilken via Wikimedia

Eucalypts’ popularity has been driven chiefly by their rapid growth; short rotation times including through coppicing; and adaptability to a very wide variety of sites and climatic conditions (Paine et al. 2011; Crous et al. 2019). Also, these trees are an important source of the short-fiber pulp required for production of high-quality paper used in modern office copiers and printers (Paine et al. 2011). Plantations are increasing even in Australia, where harvesting of native forests is increasingly being restricted (Paine et al. 2011).

Pines

Pines – a genus restricted naturally to the Northern Hemisphere – is second in global popularity. South America hosts 4.6 million hectares of pine plantations (Lantschner and Villacide 2025). South America is more dependent on forestry plantations for wood production than any other region. In 2012, 88% of its industrial roundwood was produced by non-native plantations. This far exceeded the global proportion of approximately 19%.

These intensively managed plantations have enabled Brazil and Chile to become “planted forest powerhouses.” Uruguay and, more slowly, Argentina are following the same path (Payn et al. 2015). 

Documentation of the Damage

Euclaypts

The highly diverse eucalypts host an even greater diversity of fungi. As of 30 years ago, scientists were aware of more than 500 species of just one type, the leaf-infecting fungi. Additional fungi are associated with seeds, capsules, twigs, branches, and stems. Little is known about the vast majority of these fungi. Even species considered causal agents of important diseases have not yet been confirmed using Koch’s Postulates. Areas of origin for most is also unknown (Crous et al. 2019).

Crous et al. (2019) compiled information on 110 genera of fungi found on eucalypt foliage. Some genera include well-recognized primary pathogens. They name Austropuccinia and Calonectria, Coniella, Elsinoe, Pseudocercospora, Quambalaria and Teratosphaeria. Other genera are thought to include species that are opportunists that develop on stressed or dying tissues. Many other leaf fungi are putative pathogens, but unstudied. Additional fungi cause vascular wilts (e.g. Ceratocystidaceae), stem canker diseases (Cryphonectriaceae, Botryosphaeriaceae) and root diseases (e.g. Armillaria, Ganoderma) of eucalypts.

Crous et al. (2019) state that the rust Austropuccinia psidii is one of the most damaging of the foliage fungal pathogens. They consider it to be a greater threat to eucalypt plantations outside the trees’ native ranges. (The Myrtaceous species in Australia most damaged by A. psidii are in other genera.)

Two families of leaf fungi – Mycosphaerellaceae and Teratosphaeriaceae – include species that cause serious diseases. Pérez, et al. report a study in plantation in Uruguay that detected six new species. They also discovered new hosts for some known species. (Such initial detections of new fungal species in out-of-native-range plantations is a usual occurrence.)

Over the 100-year history of planting eucalyptus outside Australasia, dozens of leaf pathogens have been transported to novel regions. Crous et al. 2019 report the wide geographic breadth of many of these introductions. For example, Mycosphaerella heimii is crippling plantation forestry in five global regions – South America (Brazil and Venezuela); Asia (Indonesia and Thailand); Africa (Madagascar), Europe (Portugal); and in its presumably native Australia. A second species, M. marksii, has a similarly wide introduced range: Portugal, China and Indonesia, South Africa, Ethiopia, and Uruguay. Pérez et al. calls Mycosphaerella leaf diseases one of the most important impediments to Eucalyptus plantation forestry in Uruguay.

Although Crous et al. do not provide dates of detection, it appears that many of these leaf pathogens were introduced outside Australasia before the mid-990s, when the World Trade Organization (WTO) and International Plant Protection Convention (IPPC) came into force. Together, these agreements govern what actions phytosanitary officials may take to curtail international movement of plant pests. (To see my critique of the WTO/IPPC system, visit here.) The possible exception might be Kirramyces gauchensis, a well-known pathogen of Eucalyptus grandis in South America (Argentina and Uruguay), Hawai`i, and Africa (Uganda and Ethiopia) (Pérez, et al. 2009). Crous et al. (2019) expect another genus, Quambalaria species, to become a threat to eucalypt plantation forestry globally in the future.

Phoracantha semipunctata; photo by Umo Schmidt via Flickr

Arthropod pests have also been spread to many Eucalyptus-growing regions in North and South America, Europe and Africa since the 1980s. Some species have colonized virtually all eucalypt-growing regions, e.g., Phoracantha semipunctata. Some have – so far – appeared on only one continent.

In an effort to determine how many of these introductions have occurred after adoption of the WTO/ IPPC system, I Googled the species named by Paine et al. (2011). I used the year 2000 as the cutoff date, to allow for detection lag. Among the insect species that fit this criterion are a lerp psyllid, a leaf beetle, and two gall wasps detected in North America; a true bug, two galling insects, and a leaf beetle in South Africa; and three psyllids in Europe.

Asia stands out as having very few introduced Australian insects plaguing eucalyptus plantations. Only one insect of Australian origin is causing significant damage in this region, Leptocybe invasa. It was detected after 2000, so it might have been introduced under the WTO/IPPC regime. Many widespread species, e.g., Phoracantha semipunctata, are notably absent. Instead, large numbers of endemic insects use these trees. This contrasts with the situation in the Southern Hemisphere, where few of the numerous native insects have shifted onto eucalypts.

New Zealand has detected only two new species of Australian origin since 1999 — two psyllids. This is despite the two nations’ proximity, the large volume of trade that passes between them, and the likelihood that at least some small sap-suckers might be introduced via aerial dispersal. New Zealand is famous for its strict phytosanitary (and sanitary) policies and programs.

Eucalyptus plantation in Kwa-Zulu, South Africa

Plantations’ vulnerability has been increased by expanding reliance on clonal, artificially-induced hybridization. Developers’ goals – and initial results – are enhanced adaptation to specific environments, desired fiber characteristics, and hybrid vigor. However, these vast areas planted in genetically identical trees are sitting ducks. An insect or pathogen that overcomes the host’s defenses can spread rapidly across the entire planting.

These hybrids also can act as “bridges,” facilitating spread of fungi to formerly resistant host species. Crous et al. (2019) fear that this process will undermine resistance in Eucalyptus pellita to the pathogen Teratosphaeria destructans. Plantations in Southeast Asia and South Africa now comprise hybrids between this resistant species and the highly susceptible Eucalyptus brassiana.

Pines

As with the eucalypts, the intensively managed pine plantations are comprised of fast-growing exotic species, all at the same developmental stage, and with minimal genetic diversity, planted to maximize wood production. These practices again lead to biological homogenization and reduced resilience to pests (Villacide and Fuetealba, 2025)

In the Southern Hemisphere, Sirex noctilio has become the most significant economic pest of Pinus species. These attacks can cause up to 80% mortality. Several other Sirex species have also been introduced, all apparently in the 1980s or earlier (Wilcken et al., 2025) – before adoption of the current international phytosanitary regime. However, in 2023, a new species, Sirex obesus, was discovered causing tree mortality in pine plantations in southeastern Brazil. This species is indigenous to the United States and Mexico.

Stazione et al. (2026) discuss two other non-native pine pests that established recently in South America.

Analysis of mitochondrial DNA of Orthotomicus erosus points to a western Eurasian lineage. The low genetic diversity of the introduced population in Argentina and Uruguay suggests a single or limited introduction event followed by regional spread.

The source region of Cyrtogenius luteus is more difficult to determine but is probably somewhere in China. The higher haplotype diversity might reflect multiple introductions. Again, shared haplotypes between Argentina and Uruguay countries indicates a contiguous regional spread, possibly driven by extensive pine plantations & intra-regional trade (Stazione et al. 2026)

Policy Aspects

Some scientists express concern about the failure of international phytosanitary measures. But are their countries speaking up in regulatory bodies, especially the International Plant Protection Convention?

Studies by Crous et al. (2019) and Pérez et al. (2009) clearly show that pathogens from Australia continue to be transported to regions where eucalypt plantations are grown. This happens despite most of the movement of genetic material being in the form of seeds – which should be less likely to transport pathogens than trade in plants. Pérez et al. (2009) explicitly raise concerns about the effectiveness of current quarantine procedures. Crous et al. (2019) state that quarantines continue to fail in many parts of the world.

Burgess and Wingfield (2017) list pathogens that have spread widely since the beginning of the 21st Century: Austropuccinia psidii, Calonectria (= Cylindrocladium) eudonaviculata (=Cylindrocladium buxicola), Ceratocystis lukuohia and C. huliohia introduced to Hawai`i. I add that insect-vectored diseases such as Euwallacea species carryingFusarium fungi have also experienced a burst of introductions around the globe since 2000.

Crous et al. (2019) attribute this failure partially to the enormous difficulty of applying effective quarantine to the huge volumes of planting material traded globally. Another factor is undoubtedly the poor understanding of microbial species, their pathogenicity, hosts, pathways of spread, even taxonomies. Some genera cannot be grown in culture.

Furthermore, pathogens’ impacts vary, possibly due to environmental conditions of the location or differing virulence on different hosts. Finally, with so many fungi and so little knowledge, it is difficult to separate true disease agents from multiple secondary infections.

Crous et al. (2019) express the hope that increased recognition of the importance of pathogens, along with improved detection and identification tools, will clarify patterns of spread. But is that enough? Are there no policy changes needed?

Crous et al. (2019) also warn us about additional pathways for spreading pathogens. Some potential pathogens of eucalypts have been moved on plants of other, related genera. Furthermore, Botryosphaeriaceae have been detected in the skins of mangoes (Mangifera indica) and avocados (Persea americana). Both of these fruits move globally in large volumes.

mangoes; photo by Obsidian Soul via Wikimedia

Regarding insects, Paine et al. (2011) focus on a concern that species native to the plantation countries and generalist herbivores from other parts of world will invade Australia and threaten eualypts in their native ranges. See other blog They also call for research to understand international pathways, develop detection methods, improve understanding of patterns of host suitability, susceptibility, and selection.

Villacide and Fuetealba (2025) note that while the introductory pathway for that new species, Sirex obesus, has not been determined, they suspect it might have been wood packaging materials. Villacide and another colleague (Lantschner and Villacide 2025) suggest an initial step would be for Argentina and other countries in the region to negotiate with Brazil to adopt more protective protocols governing trade in wood products, including wood packaging.

I have repeatedly advocated strengthening regulation of wood packaging. Such measures could improve protection of Earth’s forests from pests that use a well-documented high-risk introductory pathway. To see my arguments and underlying data, scoll down below the “archives” to “Categories” and click on “wood packaging”.

SOURCES

Burgess, T.I. and M.J. Wingfield. 2017. Pathogens on the Move: A 100-Year Global Experiment with Planted Eucalypts. Bioscience. Volume 67, Issue 1, January 2017. https://doi.org/10.1093/biosci/biw146

Crous, P.W., M.J. Wingfield, R. Cheewangkoon, A.J. Carnegie, T.I. Burgess, B.A. Summerell, J. Edwards, P.W.J. Taylor, and J.Z. Groenewald. 2019. Folia pathogens o eucalypts. Studies in Mycology 94:125-298 (2019).

Lantschner, V. and J. Villacide. 2025. Invasion Potential of the Recently Established Woodwasp Sirex obesus. Neotropical Entomology. (2025) 54:117  https://doi.org/10.1007/s13744-025-01347-6

Paine, T.D., M.J. Steinbauer, and S.A. Lawson. 2011. Native and Exotic Pests of Eucalyptus: A Worldwide Perspective. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 2011. 56:181-201

Payn, T., J-M. Carnus, P. Freer-Smith, M. Kimberley, W. Kollert, S. Liu, C. Orazio, L. Rodriguez, L. Neves Silva, M.J. Wingfield. 2015. Changes in planted forests and future global implications. Forest Ecology and Management 352 (2015)

Pérez,, C.A., M.J. Wingfield, N.A. Altier, and R.A. Blanchette. 2009. Mycosphaerellaceae and Teratosphaeriaceae associated with Eucalyptus leaf diseases and stem cankers in Uruguay For. Path. 39 (2009) 349–360   doi: 10.1111/j.1439-0329.2009.00598.x www3.interscience.wiley.com

Stazione, L., Soliani, C., Cognato, A. et al. Reconstructing the invasion history of the bark beetles Orthotomicus erosus & Cyrtogenius luteus (Coleoptera, Curculionidae, Scolytinae) in South America. Biol Invasions 28, 49 (2026). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10530-026-03779-6

Villacide, J. and A. Fuetealba. 2025. Pests in plantations: Challenging traditional productive paradigms in the Southern Cone of America. Forest Ecology and Management 597 (2025) 123127

Wilcken, C.F., T.A. da Mota, C.H. de Oliveir, V.R. de Carvalho, L.A. Benso, J.A. Gabia, S.R.S. Wilcken, E.L. Furtado, N.M. Schiff, M.B. de Camargo, M.F. Ribeiro. 2025. Sirex obesus (Hymenoptera: Siricidae) as invasive pest in pine plantations in Brazil. Scientific Reports. 2025. 15:22522  https://doi.org/10.1038/541598-025-06418-7

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

Threat to Native Myrtaceae in South America

Blepharocalyx salicifolius – a tree in the Myrtaceae native to South America on which found symptoms similar to those caused by Mycosphaerellaceae or Teratosphaeriaceae; photo by Pablo di Flores via Wikimedia

Pests that have followed their hosts to plantations outside the trees’ native ranges might threaten native plants in their new, introduced ranges. That is, the countries where the plantations are located.

Eucalypts

Eucalypts are now the most widely planted hardwood timber taxon in the world (Paine et al 2011). The 700 – 800 species in the three genera considered “eucalypts” (Angophora, Corymbia, and Eucalyptus) host a highly diverse fungal community — more than 500 species have been identified of just one type, leaf-infecting fungi (Crous et al. 2019).

As I described in a related blog, link dozens of leaf pathogens have been transported to countries hosting eucalypt plantations. Among them, two families – Mycosphaerellaceae and Teratosphaeriaceae – are prominent in both numbers of introductions and potential to cause serious diseases.

Nunez Chapa

Pérez et al. (2009) reported that a relatively large number of Mycosphaerellaceae and Teratosphaeriaceae are found on Eucalyptusin Uruguay. The authors cite one troubling case of host shifting: Mycosphaerella lateralis is causing leaf disease on a Musa cultivar (banana!) which is not in the Myrtaceae.

A follow-up study by the same authors (Pérez et al. 2013) surveyed several native forests, paying special attention to those located close to Eucalyptus plantations. They found five species belonging to the Mycosphaerellaceae and Teratosphaeriaceae clades on native Myrtaceous trees; three of these had previously been reported on Eucalyptus in Uruguay. Those occurring on both Eucalyptus and native Myrtaceae included Pallidocercospora heimii, Pseudocercospora norchiensis, and Teratosphaeria aurantia. A fourth species, Mycosphaerella yunnanensis, not previously recorded in Uruguay, was found on the leaves of two native Myrtaceous hosts. Pérez et al. (2013) believe circumstances indicate that all these fungi have been introduced. They warn that these apparent jumps to new hosts have the potential to result in serious disease problems and they should be carefully monitored. This finding is more than a decade old; I have not found a more recent report.

On the global level, Pérez et al. (2013) report, at least 23 species of Mycosphaerellaceae and Teratosphaeriaceae have been found on non-Eucalyptus species in the Myrtaceae. These hosts are in several plant orders, including Myrtales, Proteales, Fabaes and Apiales. The authors express “considerable concern” about the apparent ease of movement in these fungi between hosts. I have been unable to learn more details about these introductions.

Arthropod pests have also been spread to many Eucalyptus-growing regions in North and South America, Europe, and Africa since the 1980s – but not to Asia or New Zealand (Paine et al. 2011). blog

Myrrhinium atropurpureum – another South American plant in the Myrtaceae on which symptoms found; photo by Prof. Atilio L, Botanical Garden of Uruguay

Pines

Pines – a genus restricted naturally to the Northern Hemisphere – is second in popularity for intensively managed plantations. South America has 4.6 million hectares of pine plantations (Lantschner and Villacide 2025). Most are in Brazil, Chile, Uruguay, and Argentina (Payn et al. 2015). 

Cinara cupressi; photo by LBM via Wikimedia

As I reported in an earlier blog, some of the insect pests that followed pines to South America have entered native forests. The most alarming of which I am aware is the aphid Cinara cupressi. It attacks the native conifer Austrocedrus chilensis, which forms pure and mixed stands with southern hemisphere beech (Nothofagus spp.) across approximately 160,000 hectares (Villacide and Fuetealba 2025). Cordilleran cypress is also under attack by the oomycete Phytophthora austrocedri, an oomycete of unknown origin.

Some scientists express concern about phytosanitary measures … but are their countries speaking up in meetings of the International Plant Protection Convention?

Studies by Crous et al. and Pérez et al. clearly show that pathogens from Australia continue to be transported to regions where eucalypt plantations are grown – despite the fact that most of the movement of tree genetic material is in the form of seeds – which should be less likely to transport pathogens than trade in plants. Pérez et al. (2009) explicitly raise concerns about the effectiveness of current quarantine procedures. Crous et al. (2019) state that the quarantines continue to fail in many parts of the world.

See my critique of the international phytosanitary system under the IPPC by visiting the Fading Forest II report (see link below) and reading other blogs under the categories “invasive species policy” and “plants as vectors of pests”.

SOURCES

Crous, P.W., M.J. Wingfield, R. Cheewangkoon, A.J. Carnegie, T.I. Burgess, B.A. Summerell, J. Edwards, P.W.J. Taylor, and J.Z. Groenewald. 2019. Foliar pathogens of eucalypts. Studies in Mycology 94:125-298 (2019)

Lantschner, V. and J. Villacide. 2025. Invasion Potential of the Recently Established Woodwasp Sirex obesus. Neotropical Entomology. (2025) 54:117  https://doi.org/10.1007/s13744-025-01347-6

Paine, T.D., M.J. Steinbauer, and S.A. Lawson. 2011. Native & Exotic Pests of Eucalyptus: A Worldwide Perspective. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 2011. 56:181-201

Payn, T., J-M. Carnus, P. Freer-Smith, M. Kimberley, W. Kollert, S. Liu, C. Orazio, L. Rodriguez, L. Neves Silva, M.J. Wingfield. 2015. Changes in planted forests & future global implications. Forest Ecology and Management 352 (2015)

Pérez, C.A., M.J. Wingfield, N.A. Altier, and R.A. Blanchette. 2009. Mycosphaerellaceae & Teratosphaeriaceae associated with Eucalyptus leaf diseases & stem cankers in Uruguay For. Path. 39 (2009) 349–360   doi: 10.1111/j.1439-0329.2009.00598.x www3.interscience.wiley.com

Pérez, C.A., M.J. Wingfield, N. Altier, and R.A. Blanchette. 2013. Species of Mycosphaerellaceae and Teratosphaeriaceae on native Myrtaceae in Uruguay: evidence of fungal host jumps. Fungal Biology Volume 117, Issue 2, February 2013.

Villacide, J. and A. Fuetealba. 2025. Pests in plantations: Challenging traditional productive paradigms in the Southern Cone of America. Forest Ecology and Management 597 (2025) 123127

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

Pest Threats to Eucalypts and Australia

Chilecomadia valdiviana – one of the South American moths that attack Eucalyptus; photo by Natural History Museum of London via Wikimedia

Fifteen years ago, Paine, Steinbauer, and Lawson (2011) worried that insects in South America, Africa, Asia, and Europe that adapt to attacking Eucayptus trees planted there might be introduced to Australasia and threaten the genus in its native range. Their analysis applies to species in all three genera considered to be “eucalypts” — Angophora, Corymbia and Eucalyptus.

Some insects native to those continents have made this host shift already. Paine, Steinbauer, and Lawson reported that such host switching was especially prevalent among lepidopterans. They name several from Brazil, the Chilean cossid moth, Chilecomadia valdiviana, and southern African Coryphodema tristis. In their view, Brazilian eucalypt plantations’ proximity to native vegetation facilitates host-switching. Still, at that time they thought that there were no established pathways for introduction of the South American moths to Australia.

Host-switching is exceptionally common in Asia. Paine, Steinbauer, and Lawson (2011) thought the risk was greatest from insects on native eucalypts in near-neighbors Papua New Guinea, Timor, and The Philippines. An earlier risk assessment evaluating 10 insect species from the region concluded that most are polyphagous and probably switched to eucalypts. Two woodborers – Agrilus opulentus and A. sexsignatus –seem to have coevolved with Eucalyptus deglupta in New Guinea and The Philippines.

According to the same authors, most of the insects that have switched hosts are either polyphagous or normally feed on other myrtaceous species native to these regions. Thus, the Brazilian moth Thyrinteina arnobia feeds on Psidium guajava and several other Myrtaceae. Sarsina violascens is also a pest of Psidium species, as well as species in the Asteraceae, and Oleaceae. And the foliar rust Austropuccinia psidii was first described from Psidium guajava in Brazil and boasts a wide host range in the Myrtaceae in South America. It has been introduced to many regions with plants in the Myrtaceae, notably Hawai`i, Australia, South Africa, New Caledonia, and New Zealand. At least 15 Myrtaceae species in Australia are threatened with extinction.

Still, few non-native insects were damaging eucalypts in Australia’s native forests or plantations as of 2011. Those few are highly polyphagous. Several, if not most, were introduced in the first half of the 20th Century.

Why so few? Paine, Steinbauer, and Lawson (2011) suggest three possibilities: (a) Australia’s diverse endemic insects already occupy most niches, so they exclude new, foreign competitors; (b) most introduced insects were not previously exposed to Myrtaceae in their native range; and (c) Australia has strong quarantine procedures aiming to limit introductions of non-native herbivores.

The fact that none of the introduced insects has adapted to feed significantly on mature eucalypts’ above-ground tissues seems to me to point to protection provided by the adult trees’ phytochemicals and leaf structure. Paine, Steinbauer, and Lawson (2011) discuss some aspects of leaf structure and wax coatings.

As to Australia’s quarantine procedures, as I reported before, the country has been much less proactive regarding plant pests and diseases that threaten tree species rather than agricultural crops. Significant new programs were established only after 2000, when Plant Health Australia (PHA) was incorporated. The PHA is supposed to facilitate preparedness and response arrangements between governments and industry for plant pests (once an alien pest has become established, management becomes responsibility of the land manager). In 2005, federal, state, and territorial governments and plant industry bodies signed a legally-binding agreement — the Emergency Plant Pest Response Deed (EPPRD).  As of 2022, 38 were engaged. It sets up a process to implement management and funding of agreed responses to the detection of exotic plant pests – including cost-sharing and owner reimbursement.

Still, studies documented significant gaps in post-border forest biosecurity systems and the country’s response to the anticipated introduction of the foliar rust Austropuccinia psidii was disappointing. This prompted yet another initiative: development of the National Forest Biosecurity Surveillance Strategy (NFBSS) in 2018. The strategy was; accompanied by an Implementation Plan and appointment of a National Forest Biosecurity Coordinator. The forest sector fund a significant proportion of the proposed activities for the first five years. Still, Drs. Carnegie and Nahrung thought that in-country forest pest surveillance was still too fragmented.

Paine, Steinbauer, and Lawson (2011) consider the Asian spongy moths Lymantria dispar and Orgyia thyellina to pose serious threats. Five eucalypt species were assessed to be at risk of attack as are two preferred host oaks in Europe, Quercus pubescens and Q. robur. They note high volumes of imports from East Asia of containers, vehicles, and machinery, which are known to transport spongy moth egg-masses. It is not known whether the numerous natural enemies of Australia’s diverse lymantriid fauna [which includes four in the genus Lymantria] might provide some protection. These experts also worried that the highly polyphagous Asian longhorned beetle (Anoplophora glabripennis) might arrive in Australia. Eucalypts are not recognized as hosts.

Australia has adopted an enhanced surveillance program for ships arriving from Asian and European Lymantria ranges during female flight periods. Described here. Nahrung and Carnegie (2021) though that the high priority assigned to Lepidoptera exceeded the actual risk; only two non-native species had established in Australia over 130 years.

Paine, Steinbauer, and Lawson (2011) suggest several research topics aimed at reducing the risk to eucalypts in Australia. These include interactions between these insects and mechanisms by which insects adapt to new hosts; host chemistry and resistance mechanisms), chemical ecology (including host selection), population and community dynamics, including possible biocontrol agents, and pathway and risk analysis.

On the other hand, Carnegie and Nahrung (2019) called for developing more effective methods of detection, especially of Hemiptera and pathogens. They also promoted national standardization of data collection. Finally, they advocated inclusion of technical experts from state governments, research organizations and industry in developing and implementing responses to pest incursions. They noted that surveillance and management programs must expect and be prepared to respond to  introductions of unanticipated species. They had found that 85% of the pests detected over the last 20 years—and 75% of subsequently mid-to high-impact species established—were not on high-priority pest list.

SOURCES

Carnegie A.J. and H.F. Nahrung. 2019. Post-Border Forest Biosecurity in AU: Response to Recent Exotic Detections, Current Surveillance and Ongoing Needs. Forests 2019, 10, 336; doi:10.3390/f10040336 www.mdpi.com/journal/forests

Nahrung, H.F. and A.J. Carnegie. 2021. Border interceptions of forest insects established in Australia: intercepted invaders travel early and often. NeoBiota 64: 69–86. https://doi.org/10.3897/neobiota.64.60424

Paine, T.D., M.J. Steinbauer, and S.A. Lawson. 2011. Native & Exotic Pests of Eucalyptus: A Worldwide Perspective. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 2011. 56:181-201

Native & Exotic Pests of Eucalyptus: A Worldwide Perspective

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

A New Year …Will there be a new priority on countering invasive species?

Alaska yellow cedar (Chamaecyparis nootkatensis); one of the species vulnerable to Phytophthora austrocedri; APHIS has determined it is too late to try to slow its spread. Photo by Nucatum amygdalarum via Wikimedia

On 30 December 2025, US Department of Agriculture Secretary Brooke L. Rollins issued a Secretary’s Memorandum setting five new priorities for research and development. One is to protect agriculture from invasive species. Another is to resolve longstanding trade barriers due to sanitary and phytosanitary concerns.

The Secretary’s intention is to strengthen US agriculture to benefit both farmers and consumers. He justifies the action by claiming that President Lincoln’s original purpose in establishing USDA was to acquire and diffuse useful information on subjects connected with agriculture. According to this interpretation, Lincoln recognized that working to improve agriculture and secure the nation’s food supply would benefit everyone. The emphasis on research and development was reiterated by the almost simultaneous adoption of the Morrill Act of 1862, which created the system of land-grant universities and development of the Cooperative Extension System via the Smith-Lever Act of 1914.

The memorandum specifies five priority areas of research to be pursued by all USDA agencies and offices – to the maximum extent permitted by law and in accordance with any applicable regulations and procedural requirements.

  1. Increasing Profitability of Farmers & Ranchers — especially reducing volatility in profitability. Goals include reducing inputs or increasing mechanization and automation.
  2. Expanding Markets for US agricultural products. Two approaches are mentioned: generating science and data to resolve longstanding sanitary and phytosanitary trade barriers; and expanding use of agricultural commodities in novel biobased products and bioenergy.
  3. Protecting the Integrity of American agriculture from Invasive Species. The memorandum lists four examples of current invasive pest and pathogen threats: new world screwworm in Mexico; continued westward expansion of spotted lanternfly; persistence of highly pathogenic avian influenza in poultry flocks; and citrus greening. It notes that invasive species threaten both agriculture and natural resources. The research is to focus on new and effective methods for preventing, detecting, controlling,and eradicating these threats.
  4. Promoting Soil Health to Regenerate Long-Term Productivity of Land. The research is to promote soil health practices, increase water-use efficiency, & reduce the need for inputs.
  5. Improving Human Health through Precision Nutrition and Food Quality. Research on “precision nutrition” is said to improve understanding of how healthy dietary patterns impact individuals. Research will also focus on increasing foods’ nutritional content and quality.
Vaccinium myrtillus (photo by Anneli Salo via WikiMedia); one of several species in genera shared with North America that are infected by Phytophthora spp in the Italian alps

The memorandum also instructs USDA’s Office of the Chief Scientist (that is, the Under Secretary for Research, Education, & Economics) to coordinate these priorities within USDA and among key partners in other federal agencies.

Does This Policy Mean Substantially Stronger USDA Efforts to Counter Bioinvasions?

Can we expect new energy in USDA’s programs aimed at managing non-native forest pests and invasive plants that damage forests, wetlands, grasslands, and other natural systems? The first paragraph of the memorandum states that it is USDA policy to reaffirm a focus on the Department’s original objectives of maximizing and promoting American agriculture; ensuring a safe, nutritious, and secure food supply; enhancing rural prosperity; and protecting our National Forests & Grasslands. That is promising.

The explicit recognition that invasive species pose severe threats to both agriculture and natural resources is also promising. I welcome the inclusion of two plant pests among the examples. Livestock diseases usually receive far more attention in USDA pronouncements.

I note three caveats:

  • The prominence of enhancing markets for US agricultural exports (# 2). In the past, this longstanding emphasis has led to undercutting phytosanitary agencies’ ability to counter suspected — but incompletely understood — pest risks. I discussed the impracticality of determining a newly detected species’ probable impacts in Chapter 3 of my report, Fading Forests II.
  • The memorandum makes no reference to implementing stronger sanitary or phytosanitary policies. In my view, the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service has sufficient knowledge to support adoption of a more assertive regulatory stance with regard to both new introductions and spread within the country? Does the memorandum signal support for such a stance by high-ranking USDA officials?

These officials have often reminded APHIS that it is not a research agency.  However, its staff do “methods development” and it funds considerable research through the Plant Pest and Disease Management and Disaster Prevention Programs – Section 7721 of the Plant Protection Act and a matching program for animal diseases.

  • The US Forest Service does have a research division – although the Trump Administration proposed its virtual elimination in early 2025. The Congressional appropriators have provided funding for USFS R&D – but those bills have not yet been enacted into law. I have complained for years that USFS R&D allocates too few resources (about 1% of the total budget) to research on introduced pests and disease pathogens. Might this new directive help fix this problem?

I hope the emphasis on protecting National Forests & Grasslands does not result in narrowing the types of invasive pests addressed.

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

Will we act to minimize sales of invasive plants?

Wisteria floribunda; photo by Jack Stane via Wikimedia

For decades, it has been clear that deliberate introduction of plant species for cultivation plays a central role in the early stages of bioinvasion by plants (and associated insects, plant pathogens, earthworms … even vertebrates. Viz. coqui frogs in Hawai`i.)

Repeatedly over the two plus decades since Sarah Reichard demonstrated this role of ornamental horticulture (see Reichard and White 2001 and Mack 2000), new studies have provided corroborative details. Publications during the past two years show the risks we are still accepting in the United States. Will we act to protect our environment?

Fertakos and Bradley (2024) found that species were likely to establish if they were introduced to as few as eight locations. However, introduction history was not a strong predictor of an established species’ ultimate invasive success. They suggest that other characteristics, like plant traits and local-scale processes (e.g., interspecific interactions), may better predict whether a plant becomes invasive.

Kinlock et al. (2025) also found that plant species that were cultivated longer or were sold by more catalogs were more likely to have “naturalized”. This conclusion was based on analysis of the behavior of nearly 4,000 species sold in nursery and seed catalogs in the continental United States over 200 years. Nearly 41% of these species naturalized somewhere in the “lower 48” states. Unfortunately, they do not discuss what proportion of these species are truly damaging invaders.

Neither Fertakos and Bradley (2024) nor Kinlock et al. (2025) mention the concept of a lag between a species’ establishment and recognized symptoms of invasiveness. Has this concept been repudiated?

Evans et al. (2024) were focused on analyzing which regions of the eastern United States are likely to suffer the worst plant invasions under climate change. In this context, they worry that people will assist non-native plant species’ movement to newly suitable habitats. Evans et al. urge prioritizing for state regulation species in the ornamental trade that are projected to remain or become abundant under the new climate conditions. They say we Americans are poorly prepared to take this action, however, because plant sales are so poorly regulated and only 10% of land managers in eastern North America monitor for new invasive taxa. They say this is because the managing agencies lack of funding and personnel. After 2025’s losses of programs, appropriations, grants, and staff, this deficit is probably worse – not just for federal agencies but also the many state, local, and volunteer programs that have been supported by federal funding.

Beaury et al. (2024) investigated whether plant species recognized as invasive are sold in the same locations as where they are invasive. They found that half of the 89 species named as invasive were sold by a nursery within 21km of an observed record of invasion. The authors say that data gaps mean that these findings underestimate the number of species sold near locations of documented invasions. They warn that at least 25 species are sold by one or more nurseries located in an area that is currently unsuitable for those species, but that will become more suitable for invasion as temperatures warm. Like Evans et al. (2024), they urge proactive regulation to limit these species’ spread.

burning bush Euonymus, Japanese honeysuckle, & English ivy invading a bottomland hardwood site in Fairfax County, Virgina; photo by F.T. Campbell

U.S. Regulatory response is completely inadequate

Beaury et al. (2023) call for regulating the nursery trade in a manner consistent with the scope of the horticultural trade – sales by both e-commerce and brick and mortar stores go to customers far outside a specific state’s jurisdiction. Despite the interstate nature of the trade, sales of horticultural plants are regulated primarily by state governments. Even when a state does restrict the sale of a specified list of invasive plants, the regulations are outdated, tend to include only a few weeds that plague agriculture rather than those that invade natural systems, or are irregularly enforced. The result is a checkerboard of places where a species may legally be offered for sale next to places where that sale is prohibited. Finally, the regulations are reactive; they rarely include plants in anticipation of their spread to new areas. Beaury et al. (2023) call this as a missed opportunity to reduce the likelihood of ornamental escapes.

Evans et al. (2024) also note that online plant sales are relatively unregulated, and state regulations are inconsistent.

Under the Constitution, the appropriate entity for regulating interstate commerce is the federal government. The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service is responsible for populating and managing the federal noxious weed list. Unfortunately, APHIS lists only those taxa that qualify as quarantine pests under the definition of that term in the International Plant Protection Convention (IPPC) Glossary of Phytosanitary Terms. This means that the taxon is either not yet present in the United States or, if present, is not widely distributed and is being officially controlled. Under these criteria, the federal noxious weed list is required to exclude nearly all the invasive plant species sold by the nursery trade. 

To counter this enormous regulatory failure, many associations – native plant societies, regional or state invasive plant councils, etc. – publish their own lists of invasive plants. They often encourage their members and the public to either avoid planting these species voluntarily or to plant predominantly native plants. Also, these stakeholders urge nurseries to halt sales of invasive species voluntarily. Dr. Douglas Tallamy points out that even non-invasive, non-native plants disrupt food webs.

These voluntary efforts have yielded some success. But they have not resulted in adequate protection for our ecosystems.

Will Americans choose to invigorate the regulatory system? At a minimum, can we urge neighboring states to adopt a regional approach? More difficult, but also more effective, would be to persuade Congress to strengthen APHIS’ invasive plant regulations to outlaw interstate sales of at least those species documented to be invasive.

Cortadera selloana; picture by Alex Borland via PublicDomainPictures.net

Do you have other suggestions?

SOURCES

Beaury, E.M., J.M. Allen, A.E. Evans, M.E. Fertakos, W.G. Pfadenhauer, B.A. Bradley. 2023. Horticulture could facilitate invasive plant range infilling and range expansion with climate change. BioScience 2023 0 1-8 https://doi.org/10.1093/biosci/biad069

Evans, A.E., C.S. Jarnevich, E.M. Beaury, P.S. Engelstad, N.B. Teich, J.M. LaRoe, B.A. Bradley. 2024. Shifting hotspots: Climate change projected to drive contractions and expansions of invasive plant abundance habitats. Diversity and Distributions 2024;30:4154

Fertakos, M.E. and B.A. Bradley. 2024. Propagule pressure from historic U.S. plant sales explains establishment but not invasion. Public? doi: 10.1111/ele.14494.

Fridley, J.D., P.J. Bellingham, D. Closset-Kopp, C.C. Daehler, M.S. Dechoum, P.H. Martin, H.T. Murphy, J. Rojas- Sandoval, D. Tng. 2025. A general hypothesis of forest invasions by woody plants based on whole-plant carbon economics.

Kinlock, N.L., D.W. Adams, W. Dawson, F. Essl, J. Kartesz, H. Kreft, M. Nishino, Jan Pergl, P. Pyšek, P. Weigelt and M. van Kleunen. 2025. Naturalization of ornamental plants in the United States depends on cultivation and historical land cover context. Ecography 2025: e07748 doi: 10.1002/ecog.07748

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

Urban centers as plant invasion “hotspots” – do global data fail to focus on most important?

Leucanthemum vulgare (ox-eye daisy); ranked by EICAT as “major impact”; photo via picryl

Because urban centers are “hotspots” of species introductions and reservoirs supporting their spread into areas less altered by human activity, a global group of scientists (Richardson et al. 2025) sought to determine whether the same plant species naturalize in urban areas around the world and – if so – where most of those plant species originate.

They chose to pursue this question because urban areas share many interacting environmental and biotic features that they thought might partially overcome the distinct biomes of the continents. These shared features include the prominence of impervious surfaces; increased habitat heterogeneity; eutrophication; fragmentation of any remaining semi-natural habitats; complex human-influenced disturbance regimes; diverse opportunities for dispersal; novel biotic assemblages and interactions; and human facilitation of non-native species’ colonization and local species’ extinction. In addition to the similarities of the receiving ecosystems, these commonalities are facilitated by shared introduction pathways – although Richardson et al. to not pursue this aspect.

The scientists consulted global invasive plant databases to compile a list of 7,792 plant species recorded as naturalized in one or more of 553 urban centers on all six continents (all except Antarctica). Just over 300 species (4%) were reported on all six continents. They call them the “omnipresent” taxa. Further refinement resulted in a list of 96 species that are particularly widespread, defined as being present in more than half of the urban centers of Oceania, North and South America, and Europe. These 96 species are present in a lower proportion of cities in Asia and Africa. Richardson et al. proposed that these species be folded into a new ecological category, the “urban florome”.

I wonder whether this set of species tells us more about biases in the data than the actual “urban florome”. First, 87% of the 96 “most widespread” species (n= 84) are annual or perennial herbs. Only seven tree, six vine, and six shrub or subshrub species were included among the 96 species. In other words, global lists of invasive species are heavily slanted toward species that thrive in disturbance. Is this surprising? As another study (Kinlock et al. 2025) notes, disturbance is ubiquitous!

Second, only a third of the “urban florome” species have been formally evaluated using the Environmental Impact Classification for Alien Taxa (EICAT) system. Of these 32 species, only six were categorized as having a “major” or “massive” impact. Richardson et al. (2025) conclude that many of the species on the most widespread list are human commensals that have few or negligible known impacts.

Still, this finding might underestimate their impacts. First, as noted, two-thirds have not been evaluated. Second, impacts important in urban systems might not be those that increase a species’ rank based on impacts to natural systems (Richardson et al.). Those with substantial nuisance value in the urban setting still require management. Of course, some of the species have severe impacts in both natural and urban ecosystems. For example, Ailanthus altissima causes major infrastructural damage and pollen allergies, while Robinia pseudoacacia alters soil fertility. Both reduce species richness.

Ailanthus

I note that these examples are both trees – which constitute only 7 of the 96 species. Fridley et al. report that trees and shrubs have severe impacts in closed forest systems. I suggest that since many of the urban areas in temperate, subtropical, and tropical regions are probably located in formerly forested areas, remnant (semi-)natural stands and even recreational parks have probably been invaded by these high-impact species. Surely that is more important – at least as regards the level/intensity of the non-native plant species’ impact on biodiversity – than the annual weeds growing along highway verges.

Richardson et al. fear that many cities also have substantial invasion debt. The note specifically that due to the heat island effect, species that can now survive only in cities are likely to spread into surrounding rural and natural areas as temps increase. Thus, these species amplify the urban source effect of plant invasions.

Generalities

Richardson et al. call attention to certain parts of the world acting as ‘factories’ for the evolution of plant species that are well equipped to become invasive when intro to new regions. They name Australian woody flora — although only one species, Melia azedarach, is included among the 96 most widespread species. They also name African grasses and Europe (no taxa specified).

Richardson et al. say that while non-native species in urban areas have usually been described as “passengers” taking advantage of anthropomorphic environmental change, bioinvasions are increasingly recognized as drivers of secondary changes that alter the capacity of these ecosystems to deliver key ecosystem services, or even create disservices. These modifications occur in urban as well as more natural environments.

Regional Differences

Richardson et al. developed lists of the most widespread naturalized urban species for each continent (‘continental lists’). Eighty-seven percent of the 96 “most widespread” species are present in cities of North America, 80% in cities of Oceania, and 34% in European cities. Only 17% of the “widespread” species are present in cities of South America, 13% in cities of Africa or Asia.

While there is considerable overlap regarding species found on several continents, Europe’s urban florome differed significantly from those of the other continents.

The principal source region for these naturalizing species was temperate Asia (145 records); followed by Europe (128 records) and Africa (121 records). Lower numbers came from tropical Asia (95 records); South America (54) records; North America (53 records); and Oceania (8 records). Europe has received 50% of its widespread urban invasive species equally from temperate Asia and North America. Africa has received 75% of its widespread urban species from the two Americas equally.

According to these data, Oceania has been a significant contributor only to South America. I am surprised given the publicized problems caused by Australian Acacia and Hakea in South Africa. I guess these trees are more invasive in the vicinity of urban areas rather than in the cities themselves.

Richardson et al. note a highly skewed relationship between North and South America: while 15.4% of species naturalized in South American cities come from North America, only 2.7% of naturalized species in North American cities are from South America.

Lepidium didymum – brassica from South America introduced widely, including throughout California; photo by Miguel A.C. via Pl@ntnet

Richardson et al. found a distinct division between the “Old” and “New” Worlds (defined by whether the soil was historically cultivated by plough vs. hoe). The latter has more naturalized species (9,905 taxa vs 7,923 taxa), although the “Old World” covers a larger area. Citing di Castri (1989), they suggest that the much longer history of intense human-mediated disturbances in Europe might have allowed its flora to adapt to coexist w/ humans. I wonder, however, whether it is just too difficult to distinguish introductions that occurred millennia ago.

Richardson et al. also found an “echo” from European colonization — strengthened by activities of acclimatization societies. The result is that the continents with longer histories of European colonization, i.e., South and North America and Oceania, have more widespread naturalized plant species than do Africa and Asia.

SOURCES

Fridley, J.D., P.J. Bellingham, D. Closset-Kopp, C.C. Daehler, M.S. Dechoum, P.H. Martin, H.T. Murphy, J. Rojas- Sandoval, D. Tng. 2025. A general hypothesis of forest invasions by woody plants based on whole-plant carbon economics.

Kinlock, N.L., D.W. Adams, W. Dawson, F. Essl, J. Kartesz, H. Kreft, M. Nishino, Jan Pergl, P. Pyšek, P. Weigelt and M. van Kleunen.  Naturalization of ornamental plants in the United States depends on cultivation and historical land cover context. Ecography 2025: e07748 doi: 10.1002/ecog.077

Richardson, D.M., L.B. Trotta, M.F.J. Aronson, B. Baiser, M.W. Cadotte, M. Carboni, L. Celesti-Grapow, S. Knapp, I. Kühn, A.C. Lacerda de Matos, Z. Lososová, D. Li, F.A. Montaño-Centellas, L.J. Potgieter, R.D. Zenni, P. Pyšek. 2025. Here, There and Everywhere: Widespread Alien Plants in the World’s Urban Ecosystems. Global Ecology and Biogeography, 2025; 34:e70159  https://doi.org/10.1111/geb.70159

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

US imports continue falling … expected to sink further in 2026

Kevin Saville reports for the Journal of Commerce that containerized imports in 2025 are expected to be only 25.2 million TEUs, a decrease of 1.4% from 2024.

Declines are particularly large in the final months of 2025 since importers frontloaded their purchases to try to get ahead of the Trump Administration’s new tariffs. Imports for the first half of the year were up 3.6% compared with 2024 at 12.53 million TEUs. Thus, Saville’s sources expect November import levels to be 11.6% lower than in November 2024; December’s to be almost 13% lower.

Analysts expect the steeper decline to continue into the new year. Ben Hackett, of Hackett Associates, expects import volumes in the first four months of 2026 to be 10.3%, 8.5%, 16.8% , and 11% lower than the corresponding months a year earlier. The data source covers the ports of Los Angeles/Long Beach, Oakland, & Seattle & Tacoma on the West Coast; New York/New Jersey, the Port of Virginia, Charleston, Savannah, Port Everglades, Miami & Jacksonville on the East Coast; & Houston on the Gulf Coast. These are not all the maritime ports, but they are the major ones.

Another JOC reporter, Michael Angell, quoted several sources as saying they expect import volumes for all of 2026 to be flat or down 2% from 2025. Illustrating the reversal from past trends, The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey expects total container volumes in 2026 to be 8.5 million TEUs, a decline of about 2% from 2024. Since 2016, NY-NJ port container volumes have grown at an annual average of 4.2%.

As I have blogged before — see here and here — these swings in import volumes threaten to undermine programs intended to prevent introductions of wood-boring insects hitching rides in wood packaging material. While the higher volumes arriving from Asia in the first half of 2025 pose the most obvious risk, falling volumes reduce fee-based funding that support port inspectors. Another factor is the shift to suppliers other than China – primarily countries in Southeast Asia. Two beneficiaries of this shift are Vietnam and – at least initially – India. They have much better records of compliance with ISPM#15-mandated treatments for wood packaging link than does China.

A third JOC source reports that while US and European imports are down, trade volumes in Asia, Africa, the Middle East and Latin America are rising. I expect this growing trade to facilitate new pest introductions, although we will have to wait several years to see any data.  

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

The invasive risk of Eucalypts

Eucalyptus grandis (in Australia); photo by Poyt448 Peter Woodard via Wikimedia

Deus et al. 2025 (full citation at the end of this blog) have published a review of current knowledge on the invasiveness of trees in the Eucalyptus genus. They report that eucalypt plantations cover more than 30 million ha globally; they could not determine the actual extent more precisely. The area is expanding at an estimated 4% per year. Eucalypts are so popular as timber trees because of their fast growth, ease of management, wood quality and environmental tolerance.

Until recently, trees in the Eucalyptus genus were thought to pose a low invasion risk. This was because these trees have limited seed dispersal, high juvenile mortality, and were expected to lack compatible ectomycorrhizal fungi in novel environments. However, several risk assessments and reports of ongoing invasions in some locations have raised questions. So Deus et al. undertook a literature survey to try to resolve the issue.

One of the risk assessments concerns the United States; see Gordon et al. (2012). This study – completed a dozen years before Deus et al. undertook their literature survey – cited several other sources documenting harmful invasiveness of nearly a dozen species, including Eucalyptus globulus, E. camaldulensis, E. grandis, and  E. tereticornis.

Deus et al. found that the limitations listed above actually can be overcome, so they do not prevent invasions:

  • seeds can disperse farther than 100 meters from parent plants;
  • high recruitment densities can compensate for the high juvenile mortality; and
  • ectomychorrhizal fungi can be found in the root systems of introduced eucalypt plants.

In fact, several Eucalyptus species meet criteria defining invasiveness in the Australian Weed Risk Assessment system. Still, Deus et al. found that existing studies cover too few plantations and species to allow an in-depth comprehensive understanding of eucalypts’ invasion ecology.

One reason that eucalypt trees’ invasiveness remains unresolved is that the countries which have established most large Eucalyptus plantations (Brazil, India and China) have not conducted many studies. Instead, most studies have been done in Iberia and South Africa, which together host less than six percent by area of the world’s estate of eucalypt plantations.

Deus et al. say that several possible reasons have been proposed to explain why Eucalyptus is considered to pose an invasion risk by scientists in Iberia and South Africa, but not in Brazil. 

  1. The few studies in Brazil were conducted in intensively managed plantations with very short rotations, which are probably less prone to invasion than plantations managed at low intensity levels.
  2. The Brazilian plantations were established 40 to 50 years ago, whereas those in Iberia were introduced ~ 200 years ago.
  3. Iberia experiences recurrent forest fires.
  4. In Brazil, leaf eating ants attack the trees; this might reduce trees’ vigor.
  5. In Brazil, native forests dominate the environs.

Deus et al. say that these hypotheses have never been tested.

Since studies have been conducted in only a few countries, they have evaluated only a few of the species used in plantations. At least 372eucalypt species have been introduced outside their native range; nine species are planted widely. Yet most of the studies reviewed by Deus et al. covered just two species, Eucalyptus globulus (46% of the studies), and E. camaldulensis (33% of the studies). Still, these two widely cultivated species received the highest invasiveness ranking of all species reviewed (65 and 72, respectively). According to Deus et al., these scores are higher than the average score for 32 species of Acacia – a genus considered to be one of the most invasive tree genera in the world.

Other, potentially invasive species, have not received adequate attention. Deus et al. note that E. tereticornis, which is widely planted in China, India and other regions of Southern Asia, has an invasiveness score of 66, placing it second highest in the evaluation. However, only 12 of 140 articles analyzed by Deus et al. addressed this species.

These eucalypts’ high scores result from their potential to hybridize, to naturalize outside their natural habitat, and from high flammability. Other contributing factors are high seed production and ability to resprout after cutting or fire.

The analysis determined that the major drivers for Eucalyptus invasions are soil disturbance, availability of moisture (essential for seedling establishment), and fire. Recruitment density increases with harvesting and tree age; it decreases when the understory is managed. This partially explains why the abandonment of plantations might promote invasions by eucalypts.

Deus et al. fear that there might be a large “invasion debt” in the regions where few studies have been conducted. Assessments for California and Iberian Peninsula indicate that the best areas for cultivation – under either current conditions or expected new environments linked to climate change – are also those most prone to invasion. A further complication is that in some regions it might be difficult to distinguish plants escaping from small plantations from the plantations themselves. They suggest ways to overcome this difficulty: 1) surveys of recruitment along roadside, where trees would not have been planted; 2) genetic analysis of seedlings and possible parents

Another weakness is that that none of the studies considers changes in fire regime, which probably increases the areas prone to invasion.

Deus et al. think it is unlikely that eucalypt invasions will turn out to be as damaging as those of acacias or pines, but that further invasions involving more species and more regions are very likely.

Deus et al. call for considering eucalypt species’ potential invasiveness when developing strategies for the sustainable management of these plantations, including how to manage those that are no longer economically viable.

Status in the United States

The risk in the United States was evaluated by Gordon et al. in 2012. At the time, there were proposals to plant 5,000 to 10,000 ha/year in the Southeast over the next decade.

Gordon et al. adapted the Australian weed risk assessment system to evaluate 38 Eucalyptus taxa then being tested and cultivated in U.S. for pulp, biofuel, and other purposes. Their analysis concluded that 15 of these taxa posed a low risk; 14 taxa posed a high risk; and 9 taxa could not be ranked without further information. The four taxa cultivated most extensively –  E. globulus, E. camaldulensis, E. grandis, and E. tereticornis – all had high risk outcomes, as did several other taxa. Gordon et al. thought that these differences reflected both new data and differences in how the assessors reacted to insufficient data.

Gordon et al. warned that novel genotypes with unknown invasiveness were being propagated in the search for increased cold tolerance. This meant that the taxa they had assessed might not indicate of the actual long-term invasion risks associated from this genus. A major source of uncertainty is the long lag time in appearance of evidence of a tree species’ invasiveness. Only one study (as of 2012) had quantified lag time for introduced tree species; it found an average of 170 years from the time introduction to identification of the taxon as invasive. Propagule pressure also influences the lag time and the probability of invasion.

Since the bulk of expanded cultivation was expected to be in the southeast, Gordon et al. recommended that a regional assessment be conducted to more precisely specify the effects of possible differences in phenology, age at reproductive maturity, seed viability, and cold tolerance. 

Gordon et al. suggested several actions to reduce the invasion risk. First, selection and breeding strategies could aim to minimize relevant traits – especially eliminating seed production. Second, plantations could be so managed by avoiding cultivation near waterways, harvesting stems before seeds can mature, and restricting the extent of cultivation of any one taxon. More broadly, a fund could be established to cover control costs; growers would contribute the money.

What has happened in the dozen years since the analysis was published? My Google search led to publications from 2013 and earlier. I hope this indicates that no one has funded major expansions. Dr. Gordon reports that most Eucalyptus pulp is imported. ArborGen continues to breed Eucalyptus in Brazil – as I noted earlier, scientists there are not pursuing studies of possible invasiveness of eucalypts.

Still, the regional risk assessment has not been conducted. Worse, Dr. Gordon reports that the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services has exempted several species [E. amplifolia, E. benthamii, E. dorrigoensis, E. dunnii, E. grandis, E. gunni, E. nitens, E. smithii, and E. urograndis (E. grandis  E. urophylla)] from a requirement that growers obtain Non-Native Species Planting Permits. So if the market does take off, there will be no regulation by the state.

At the end of December 2025, Dr. Gordon received information from Florida Division of Plant Industry that no one has applied for a permit to grow Eucalyptus in the state other than under USDA research auspices. So my worst fears have not (yet) come to pass.

I note that in 2022, Potter, Riitters, & Guo ranked Eucalyptus grandis & E. globulus as potentially highly invasive. Their criterion was that at least 75% of stems detected by USFS Forest Inventory and Analysis (FIA) surveys were saplings or seedlings.

SOURCES

Deus, E., D.M. Richardson, F.X. Catry, F.C. Rego, J. Gaspar, M. Nereu, M. Larcombe, B. Potts, J.S. Silva. 2025. Invasion ecology of eucalypts: a review. Biol. Invasions (2025) 27:239  https://doi.org/10/1007/s10530-025-03695-1

Gordon, D.R.,S.L. Flory,.L. Cooper, and S.K. Morris. 2012. Assessing the Invasion Risk of Eucalyptus in the United States Using the Australian Weed Risk Assessment. International Journal of Forestry Research Volume 2012, Article ID 203768, 7 pages doi:10.1155/2012/203768

Potter K.M., Riitters, K.H. & Guo, Q. 2022. NIS tree regeneration indicates regional & national risks from current invasions. Frontiers in Forests & Global Change  

doi: 10.3389/ffgc.2022.966407

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org

New Sirex established in South America … threat to pine plantations + threat to native conifer from North American aphid

pine plantation near Buenos Aires; photo by Biologicadero via Wikimedia

I have learned about the introduction of a North American woodwasp, Sirex obesus, in Brazil. Forestry interests in South America are worried that this woodwasp will cause significant damage to the pine plantations occupying 4.6 million hectares on the continent.

In July 2023, experts at the Estação Experimental de Ciências Florestais at ESALQ/USP in Itatinga, São Paulo, Brazil, investigated dead and symptomatic trees of several Pinus species and subspecies. They expected the causal agent to be Sirex noctilio – a woodwasp native to Europe and North Africa that has caused considerable damage to South American pine plantations since the 1980s (Wilcken et al.).

However, the pine species attacked were not typical hosts for S. noctilio (in Brazil, loblolly pine Pinus taeda). Instead, the infected trees were Caribbean pines, i.e., Pinus caribaea hondurensis, P. caribaea bahamensis, P. caribaea caribaea, P. maximinoi, P. tecunumani. The responsible woodwasp was identified as Sirex obesus. This species is native to the southwestern United States and northern and central Mexico (Wilcken et al.). This species is closely related to S. californicus (Wilcken et al.).

A second outbreak was found in November ~ 130 km away (still in São Paulo state). Scientists have not determined whether the two São Paulo outbreaks are related. Dr. Villacide reports (pers. comm.) that the two populations genetics have been compared, but he does not have the results.

A third population has been detected in a second, neighboring, state, Minas Gerais (Wilcken to Lantschner and Villacide).

Dr. Villacide (pers. comm.) reports that Brazilian scientists are trying to delimit the extent of the outbreaks. Public and private scientists in other countries with pine plantations have begun developing responses.

This is the first record of S. obesus outside of North America (Wilckens et al.).

Little is known yet about this woodwasp’s probable impact. It is clear that it can oviposit in a wide range of pines. In its native range, S. obesus has been reported on three host species: Pinus ponderosa, P. teocote (twisted-leaf pine), and P. leiophylla (no common name; native to Chihuahua – mostly in Mexico, and border areas of New Mexico and Arizona]. In Brazil, as noted, it has been recorded on other species as well as the hybrids P. caribaea x P. elliottii and P. caribaea x P. tecunumanii (Wilcken et al.).

So for purposes of their risk assessment, Lantschner and Villacide assumed that S. obesus can affect any of the species commonly planted in the region: P. taeda, P. elliottii, P. ponderosa, P. contorta, P. caribaea, P. oocarpa, P. patula, P. radiata, and P. tecunumanii (Lantschner and Villacide).

The risk assessment predicts suitable climatic conditions for invasion by S. obesus in 48% of the areas where South American pine plantation occur, particularly in montane and high-altitude regions along the Andean corridor and central-eastern Brazil. Incorporating other factors – host distribution, proximity to invaded areas, and volume of wood imports from Brazil – identified the most vulnerable areas as in southern Brazil, northeast Argentina, the Argentine Patagonia, and central Chile (Lantschner and Villacide).

pine plantation in Argentina; photo by Tomas Asurmendi via pexels

Preliminary sampling (Wilcken et al.) indicates the impacts could be severe. Mortality varies by species: in the worst cases average mortality approached 43% on P. caribaea hondurensis but only 11% on loblolly pine (P. taeda). They expect mortality rates to increase. Another 30% of P.c. hondurensis trees are dripping resin, a sign of woodwasp oviposition. If these eggs hatch, those larvae will probably kill the affected trees. Such a result would increase total mortality of P.c. hondurensis from 43% to ~ 73%. For P. taeda, the current mortality rate of 11% could rise to 49% as an additional 38% of trees succumb. Following this logic, these areas could experience complete tree mortality within a few years. Given the extent of pine plantations, and possible mortality rates, even a partial spread of S. obesus could lead to significant econ losses.

As second factor is the number of generations per year; the higher the number, the faster woodwasp populations can increase. Wilckens et al. report that adult emergence in Pinus logs maintained in cages indicates that S. obesus could have two or three generations per year.

S. obesus seems to prefer a different climate than S. noctilio. As noted, S. obesus seems to prefer montane and high-altitude climates. S. noctilio is concentrated in lowland temperate and humid regions (Lantschner and Villacide). The newly introduced species might substantially broaden the geographic area where pine plantations might be at risk – although further research is needed to clarify this point.

S. obesus also appears to be spreading at a rapid rate — ~46 km / year. At this rate, Lantschner and Villacide say it could spread throughout all major pine plantation areas in Brazil in less than years.

Sirex woodwasps kill trees by injecting a symbiotic wood decay fungus and a phytotoxic mucus into the tree when ovipositing. The toxin weakens the tree, allowing the fungus to spread, typically killing the tree in as little as three–four months. In North America S. obesus is associated with Amylostereum chailletti. While this species has not yet been confirmed in Brazil, (Wilckens et al.). Brazilian scientists are exploring whether S. obesus might adopt the fungus already present, Amylostereum areolatum, which is associated with S. noctilio.

Two insect species known to feed on woodwasps have emerged from logs infested with S. obesus: Ibalia leucospoides (Hymenoptera: Ibaliidae) and a species of Schlettererius (Hymenoptera: Stephanidae). While these two predators have not proved to be effective controls of woodwasps by themselves, they might become part of a control program. The parasitic nematode, Deladenus siricidicola (Nematoda: Neotylenchidae) used successfully in several South Hemisphere countries to control S. noctilio has not been found in Brazil (Wilckens et al.).

Scientists don’t know the pathway by which S. obesus entered Brazil. Wilckens believes it was via wood packaging; technicians from the Ministry of Agriculture have found some pallets associated with imports that lacked the ISPM#15 mark (Wilckens et al.).

Both Lantschner and Villacide and Wilcken et al. stress the vulnerability of South American pine plantations to introduction of damaging pests. The plantations are reportedly intensively managed, even-aged, regularly spaced monocultures. These conditions can facilitate invasive species establishment and spread by providing abundant host resources and reduced natural enemy pressure. Lantschner and Villacide cite Michael Wingfield that in plantation forestry, introduction of a single pest species can damage large areas of valuable timber.

mortality caused by Sirex noctilio in a pine plantation in Argentina; photo courtesy of Jose Villacide

The family Siricidae contains more than 120 species distributed across the forests of the Northern Hemisphere. In their native ranges they are typically minor or secondary pests (Wilckens et al.). Woodwasps have demonstrated that they can be transported in international commerce – S. noctilio alone has invaded pine stands (native or exotic) in nine countries in Oceania, Africa, and South and North America. Three other species in the family — Urocerus gigas, Urocerus flavicornis and Tremex fuscicornis – have been detected in South America (Wilckens et al.). If each represents a unique threat, countries with widespread pine plantations should enhance their phytosanitary programs. Exporting parties, e.g., the United States and European Union, should assist in efforts to prevent spread of these wood borers. One major step would be to strengthen regulations governing wood packaging material. [To see my criticisms of shortfalls of the ISPM#15 system, scroll down the list of blogs to “Categories” and click on “wood packaging”.]

Lantschner and Villacide cautionthat their assessment is based on a limited record of S. obesus occurrences in its native range. This range might be restricted by factors other than climate, including geographic barriers or biotic interactions (natural enemy pressure or interspecific competition). If so, the species’ potential invasive range might be larger than the climate-based models predict.

Recommendations for management strategies

I applaud Lantschner and Villacide for proposing immediate steps to improve management of the threat posed by introduction of S. obesus. These recommendations should prioritize enhanced phytosanitary inspections of wood products moving between high-risk regions and other South American countries. They suggest that Brazil adopt bilateral agreements with its major trading partners which would specify protocols for woodwaspdetection and quarantines. [Since many of these countries already have established populations of S. noctilio they probably do not have strong phytosanitary measures targeting wood borers at present.] Lantschner and Villacide advise creation of targeted surveillance programs in southern Brazil, northeastern Argentina, Argentine Patagonia, and central Chile. They should focus on sites near major transportation hubs and border crossings. Less intense surveillance should be instituted in regions they classified as medium risk. Again, the focus should be on major points of entry for imported goods and on plantations located near the Brazilian border. They note that preventing spread of S. obesus into new areas will require not only national efforts but also regionally coordinated monitoring, research, and forest health policies.

Lantschner and Villacide also identify priority areas for future research. These include clarifying S. obesus’shost range, the environmental conditions that enable the woodwasp to establish and persist beyond its native range, dispersal rates, and whether S. obesus exhibits pulse-like pop dynamics[long periods of low density interrupted by sudden outbreaks] seen in S. noctilio.

Dr. Villacide (pers. comm.) reports that Brazilian scientists are trying to delimit the extent of the outbreaks. Public and private scientists in other countries with pine plantations have begun developing responses. Dr. Villacide has posted a video from a recent online seminar sponsored by the Southern Cone Forest Health Group. Go to https://youtu.be/uVU6CpFNhlQ?si=lqXtwJTtz5rKXfL3 or
https://sanidadforestalconosur.org/

A wider prespective

Dr. Villacide’s attention to Sirex obesus is part of his broader work on pest issues in South America’s commercial plantations. In another publication (Villacide and Fuetealba 2025; full citation at the end of this blog), he explores how to make these plantations sustainable in the face of rising threats from pests – both introduced and native to the region. Dr. Villacide and Alvaro Fuetealba report that every year 1.2 million hectares of plantations in the Southern Cone are affected by pests. Their vulnerability of will be worsened by the extreme weather events expected under climate change.  

These plantations present vast areas of homogeneous stands: ~97% of the Southern Cone planted area consists of exotic tree species – mainly Pinus and Eucalyptus. Typical plantations are high density and managed intensively – including thinning, pruning, and fertilizing – to prompt rapid growth. As Villacide and Fuetealba point out, while these practices maximize wood production efficiency, they also lead to biological homogenization and reduced resilience to pests.

They report that pine plantations are under attack by wood and bark borers that have followed pines to the region, including Sirex noctilio, Orthotomicus erosus, and Cyrtogenius luteus; and now the newly detected Sirex obesus (above). At least two fungal pathogens — Fusarium circinatum and Dothistroma septosporum – have also been introduced. The principal threat to pine plantations from native pests comes from leaf-cutting ants (Atta and Acromyrmex).Eucalyptus plantations are plagued by several insects that have arrived from Australia, including Phoracantha semipunctata, Thaumastocoris peregrinus, and Leptocybe invasa. Pests native to the region that attack Eucalyptus are the Chilean carpenter worm (Chilecomadia valdiviana) and the leaf-cutting ants.

Cordilleran cypress; photo by LBM 1948 via Wikimedia

Threat to native conifer

More worrying to me is that introduced pests have entered native forests. Villacide and Fuetealba report that the aphid Cinara cupressi is attacking the native conifer Austrocedrus chilensis. Cordilleran cypress, also called Chilean or Patagonian cedar, is an endemic, monospecific tree in the Cupressaceae family. In southern Argentina and Chile the species forms pure and mixed stands with southern hemisphere beech (Nothofagus spp.) across ~ 160,000 ha. The profile Cinara cupressi on the Global Invasive Species Database is unclear about how many species are in the species complex and their places of origin.

Cordilleran cypress is also under attack by the oomycete Phytophthora austrocedri, an oomycete of unknown origin. This pathogen is of unknown origin. It is now thought to have been present in Argentina since at least the 1960s. P. austrocedri has also been ntroduced to Europe, western Asia, and North America.

Villacide and Fuetealba advocate several actions to might diversify tree species in the plantations to reduce their vulnerability to pests. They note that this recommendation builds on foundational ecological theory, including the resource concentration and natural enemy hypotheses. Diversity-promoting actions should reach beyond any plantation to the landscape level. Managers should consider connectivity of susceptible stands, the number of nutritionally optimal host trees in the landscape, and the availability and quality of hosts in adjacent stands.

Villacide and Fuetealba say mixed plantations can provide additional ecological and economic benefits, such as enhanced stand-level productivity; production of a wider range of commercial and subsistence products; and greater resistance and resilience to natural disturbances, e.g., extreme weather events.

They warn that designing and implementing mixed plantations must reflect ecological interactions and pest dynamics as well as management. There is need for regionally coordinated experimental plantations where scientist could test how variables such as tree species composition, density and spatial arrangement, and silvicultural practices influence pest dynamics, forest productivity, and ecosystem resilience under local conditions. They suggest incorporating sentinel plantings both early-warning systems and decision-support tools at plot and regional scales. Researchers should evaluate pest-specific responses, productivity trade-offs, long-term forest health outcomes under different scenarios.

Since the plantations extend across a multinational region with few natural barriers and uniform silvicultural practices, as well as high levels of trade, so do the pest problems. Therefore, the response must also be regional – e.g., regional experimental plantations and living laboratories. A collaborative approach linking researchers, forest managers, and policymakers is essential to translate experimental findings into practice and develop adaptive, ecol grounded silvicultural strategies. Long-term ecological trials must be embedded in operational contexts and aligned across countries.

SOURCES

Lantschner, V. and J. Villacide. 2025. Invasion Potential of the Recently Established Woodwasp Sirex obesus. Neotropical Entomology. (2025) 54:117  https://doi.org/10.1007/s13744-025-01347-6

Villacide, J. and A. Fuetealba. 2025. Pests in plantations: Challenging traditional productive paradigms in the Southern Cone of America. Forest Ecology and Management 597 (2025) 123127

Wilcken, C.F., T.A. da Mota, C.H. de Oliveir, V.R. de Carvalho, L.A. Benso, J.A. Gabia, S.R.S. Wilcken, E.L. Furtado, N.M. Schiff, M.B. de Camargo, M.F. Ribeiro. 2025. Sirex obesus (Hymenoptera: Siricidae) as invasive pest in pine plantations in Brazil. Scientific Reports. 2025. 15:22522  https://doi.org/10.1038/541598-025-06418-7

Posted by Faith Campbell

We welcome comments that supplement or correct factual information, suggest new approaches, or promote thoughtful consideration. We post comments that disagree with us — but not those we judge to be not civil or inflammatory.

For a detailed discussion of the policies and practices that have allowed these pests to enter and spread – and that do not promote effective restoration strategies – review the Fading Forests report at http://treeimprovement.utk.edu/FadingForests.htm

Or

https://fadingforests.org